Rao’s Homemade Marinara is the taste-first pick in Food Network’s 2026 comparison of 20 popular supermarket sauces. Its balanced seasoning and texture earned the top spot in that test; it is not an objective winner for every palate or budget. For a lower-cost option, Food Network chose Prego Traditional, though its reviewers found it notably sweet when tasted on its own.
Which jarred tomato sauce should you buy?
Choose Rao’s Homemade Marinara if flavor is your priority and you want the leading pick from a broad supermarket comparison. Food Network heated and sampled 20 sauces by spoon and with penne, considering seasoning, texture, consistency, aftertaste, pasta coating, versatility, bread-dipping use, and whether each tasted authentic or artificial. Its reviewers praised Rao’s balanced seasoning and texture, and described the sauce as containing eight ingredients: tomatoes, olive oil, onion, garlic, basil, oregano, salt, and pepper. Read Food Network’s 2026 comparison.
There is supporting, older evidence for Rao’s: in The Washington Post’s 2023 blind test of 12 supermarket marinara options, it scored 59 and was the only sauce to receive perfect scores from three judges. Tasters praised its fresh-tasting herbs, tomato and onion pieces, and chunky-but-not-overly-chunky texture. That result is a dated panel judgment, not a guarantee that every shopper will prefer it. See The Washington Post’s 2023 taste test.
What if price matters more than the top taste-test result?
Prego Traditional: the budget comparison
Food Network named Prego Traditional its best budget sauce, noting that it offered pleasant flavor for a low-cost option. The tradeoff is sweetness: the reviewers found it sugary when tasted alone, and the guide reports 9 grams of sugar for the product it reviewed. Check the current jar’s nutrition label before relying on that figure, since product details can change. Food Network suggests Prego can serve as a recipe base and may benefit from added seasoning. Its budget designation is relative to the products and prices in that guide; it does not establish a current price per ounce or guarantee it is the cheapest jar where you shop.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
#1 Best Overall
The Washington Post’s 2023 panel also found most tasters considered Prego too sweet. But blind-test preferences vary: Epicurious’s April 8, 2026 blind test featured chefs Frank Proto, Dan Richer, and Giorgia Caporuscio, and its transcript records Carbone as the panel’s favorite alongside negative reactions to Prego. The panels used different tasters and methods, so these results show why there is no universal taste-test winner. Read Epicurious’s blind-test coverage.
How to choose a sauce for your palate and recipe
- Flavor: If you prefer a tomato-forward sauce, look for one where sweetness and acidity feel balanced rather than candy-like or sharply sour. In the Epicurious blind-test transcript, chef Frank Proto says, “When I look for a tomato sauce, I want it to be tomato forward.” The same transcript describes a preference for a middle ground between acidity and sweetness, without identifying that speaker.
- Seasoning: Consider whether you want herbs, garlic, onion, and salt to stand out or stay restrained. A sauce that tastes mild on its own can be easier to customize in a recipe; a strongly seasoned jar may need little adjustment.
- Texture: Pick smooth sauce if you want an even coating, or a chunkier style if you like visible tomato and onion pieces. Thickness also affects how well sauce clings to pasta.
- Use: For a simple pasta dinner, taste and texture matter directly. For pizza, chicken parm, or another recipe, consider whether the jar works as a base and whether you are willing to add seasoning or adjust its consistency.
How to compare price and nutrition on the shelf
Prices and formulations change, so compare the jars available to you rather than assuming a publication’s budget pick is cheapest today. Check the price per ounce, then compare serving sizes and the current Nutrition Facts panel. A lower shelf price is not necessarily a better value if the jar is smaller or the sauce does not suit the way you plan to use it.
Rank #2
- Ideal for Gifting
- Ideal for a bookworm
- Compact for travelling
The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) uses nutrition thresholds for its sauce selections: “Best Bites” have no added sugar and no more than 250 milligrams of sodium per ½-cup serving; “Honorable Mentions” may have up to 1 gram of added sugar and 350 milligrams of sodium. These are CSPI selection criteria, not a taste ranking or a universal dietary recommendation. Check the specific jar’s current label and serving size. See CSPI’s sauce criteria.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- It can be a gift option
- Comes with secure packaging
- Helpful in various ways
Rank #4
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
