Tobey Maguire ranks first among the three Spider-Man actors in Spider-Man: No Way Home, according to the most recent side-by-side estimates we could locate. A 2025 AS USA report, relaying Celebrity Net Worth figures, puts Maguire at an estimated $75 million, Tom Holland at $25 million, and Andrew Garfield at $16 million. These are secondary estimates rather than audited figures or disclosures from the actors, so the ranking is a reasonable directional answer, not a verified statement of anyone’s finances.
Who is being compared
Sony’s official film description says No Way Home connects storylines from multiple live-action Spider-Man franchises. Marvel’s coverage identifies the returning Spider-Men as Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, and Tom Holland. The comparison in this article covers only those three performers.
The estimated ranking
| Actor | Estimated net worth | Source and date of the estimate | Reported pay for No Way Home |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tobey Maguire | $75 million | AS USA, 2025, relaying Celebrity Net Worth | Not stated in the TheWrap report |
| Tom Holland | $25 million | AS USA, 2025, relaying Celebrity Net Worth | $10 million, reported by TheWrap in 2026, based on three unnamed people with knowledge of the deal |
| Andrew Garfield | $16 million | AS USA, 2025, relaying Celebrity Net Worth | Not stated in the TheWrap report |
Read the two columns separately. The net-worth column is an overall estimate of wealth. The pay column is a single reported fee for one film, and it exists for only one of the three actors in the reporting we found.
What the estimates can and cannot tell you
- They are secondhand. AS USA was relaying Celebrity Net Worth figures. Neither outlet’s figures come from tax filings, company records, or statements by the actors.
- They are dated. The estimates were published in 2025. Film fees, investments, and business deals since then may have changed the picture, and the reporting does not say when each figure was last updated.
- They do not show the method. The sources do not explain how the estimates were built, so they cannot be checked line by line.
- They do not show liquid cash or debts. A net-worth figure is a headline total. It does not separate cash, property, equity stakes, or liabilities, and it does not show income in a given year.
Why the $10 million figure does not settle the question
TheWrap reported that Holland received $10 million for No Way Home, citing three people with knowledge of the agreement who were not named. That is a useful data point about one film’s compensation, but it is not a net-worth figure. It also does not give comparable numbers for Maguire or Garfield, so it cannot be used to rank the three on pay.
#1 Best Overall
- When Dr. Strange?s spell to restore Spider-Man?s identity goes awry, Peter is forced to overcome his greatest challenge yet.
Two other common shortcuts also fail. A film’s box-office gross is not what its actors earn, and playing a role does not show how much wealth an actor has accumulated across a career.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.How to read celebrity net-worth comparisons
- Check the publication date and whether the figure is an estimate, a company-reported number, or a statement by the person.
- Keep one-film fees separate from total net worth, and do not add them together.
- Compare people on the same measure. If one actor has a fee figure and another does not, the two cannot be ranked on pay.
- Treat any ranking within a small gap as uncertain. A gap like $75 million versus $25 million is large enough to be notable within these estimates, but the estimates themselves carry the uncertainty described above.
On the estimates available, Maguire ranks first, followed by Holland and then Garfield. Those figures come from a 2025 secondary report, and no primary financial disclosure from any of the three actors was located to confirm or update them.
Rank #2
- When Dr. Strange?s spell to restore Spider-Man?s identity goes awry, Peter is forced to overcome his greatest challenge yet.
Sony says No Way Home is available through major digital retailers, including Prime Video, if you want to watch the film itself.
Quick Recap
Rank #4
- Following the events of Avengers: Endgame, our friendly neighborhood Spider-Man decides to join his best friends Ned, MJ, and the rest of the gang on a European vacation. However, Peter?s plan to leave super heroics behind for a few weeks is quickly scrapped when he begrudgingly agrees to help Nick Fury and step up to take on new threats in a world that has changed forever.
Rank #3
- Tom Holland stars as your friendly neighborhood Spider-Man in three unforgettable adventures ? HOMECOMING, FAR FROM HOME, and NO WAY HOME.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
Recommended Free Tools
