The U.S. Department of Justice announced a proposed settlement with Live Nation during the antitrust trial, but the deal did not end the case for the states that refused to join it. Six states signed on; 34 states and the District of Columbia continued to trial and won a jury liability verdict on April 15, 2026. The states’ remedies and financial penalties remained to be decided, while the DOJ settlement was still described in a proposed judgment rather than a confirmed final order in materials available through Oct. 8, 2026.
Why states called the settlement a surprise
The DOJ’s Antitrust Division and state co-plaintiffs sued Live Nation Entertainment and Ticketmaster in the Southern District of New York on May 23, 2024. Their complaint alleged anticompetitive conduct involving primary ticketing at major concert venues, concert promotion and large amphitheaters. Those were allegations at the time, not findings of liability.
The trial began in March 2026. During the trial, the DOJ and Live Nation announced a proposed settlement. States that did not join reportedly felt blindsided by the mid-trial announcement; “surprise” describes their reaction to the timing, not a finding about whether the proposed terms were adequate.
The DOJ’s March 9 notice attached a term sheet discussed in court. It said Ticketmaster would enable venues using its back-office system to distribute primary tickets through third-party marketplaces selected by the venues, with terms intended to limit restrictions on venue choice. It also addressed exclusivity and other venue and ticketing commitments. The notice said the agreement could not be final until reduced to a proposed final judgment signed by the parties and the Tunney Act requirements were met.
#1 Best Overall
- Personalized gift idea: A scratch-off surprise concert tickets, ideal for a gift to a friend or family member. You can make your own by writing down the artist and putting a scratch sticker on top. Give them this surprise reveal card and watch as they scratch off the red heart sticker to reveal your surprise artist.
- Surprise Reveal Card for Holiday, Christmas, Wedding, Birthday, Anniversary, Party Supply.Surprise your special person/s with a lovely and classic personalised boarding scratch pass.
- A great way to reveal a surprise for someone's birthday, valentines day, retirement gift, anniversary, or just because...
- Material: Crafted from high-quality coated paper, the scratch surprise boarding pass is durable and easy to write on.
- perfect gift idea: This concert tickets can be individually designed by you. Simply fill out the information on the ticket by hand, and Write your surprise artist on heart frame,then stick the scratch-off sticker on the place of the artist.
What the proposed DOJ deal covered—and who joined
Six states joined the proposed settlement: Arkansas, Iowa, Mississippi, Nebraska, Oklahoma and South Dakota. The other 34 states and the District of Columbia continued their claims at trial. The settlement proposal and the continuing state case therefore had different participants and different procedural paths.
| Issue | Proposed DOJ settlement | States that continued at trial |
|---|---|---|
| Participants | DOJ and six settling states: Arkansas, Iowa, Mississippi, Nebraska, Oklahoma and South Dakota. | Thirty-four states and the District of Columbia pursued their claims through trial. |
| Ticketing and venue terms | The March term sheet addressed third-party marketplace access through Ticketmaster’s back-office system, venue choice and exclusivity. NAAG’s summary of the proposed remedies also included a 15% cap on ticketing service fees. | The jury later found liability on state claims involving primary ticketing at major venues, among other findings; the states’ remedies were left for a separate stage. |
| Structural measures | NAAG’s summary included divestiture of long-term booking agreements for 13 amphitheaters. The proposed terms described here did not provide for a breakup of Live Nation. | Tennessee’s attorney general said a breakup was among the remedies that could be considered. No final remedy had been established in the materials available through Oct. 8, 2026. |
| Money and status | A proposed final judgment filed June 12, 2026 listed payments to the six settling states. Filing a proposed judgment does not by itself establish that it was entered or that payments were made. | The jury returned a liability verdict on April 15, 2026. Remedies and financial penalties were to be addressed separately. |
The access, fee-cap and amphitheater provisions are proposed settlement terms, not evidence that those changes had already taken effect. The deal was not a single resolution binding every state plaintiff.
Rank #2
- Unique and Creative Gift Cards: This is a fun and creative way to present a surprise can be personalized; The creative possibilities are endless and the Golden Ticket so that the recipient gets a full sense of surprise!
- Exquisite Gift Sets: In addition to the gold gift cards, 1 gold envelopes, 1matching scratch off labels and 1envelope stickers are included. Simply write on the gold gift card, attach the scratch off tag to the blank space on the gold gift card, then place the gift card in the gold envelope and present it to the recipient.
- FINISHED WITH GOLDEN FILM:Our gift voucher is finished with a golden hot-foil coating. The gold is beautiful and shiny,The tickets are rigid cardboard so they are sturdy.
- Fun and Unique Idea :This Golden Ticket is a versatile, unique idea perfect as a surprise gift, school accomplishments reward, or interactive party game centerpiece—ideal for family reunions where winners earn tickets for playful prizes or a grand finale reward,Anyone who gets this golden ticket would feel like a winner!
- Mystery Gift：These little tickets are incredibly fun,You can write any message This is a great surprise for anyone, (Example: a car for a spouse or child; it's difficult to wrap it up and if you do it's easy to know what the item is. So give an envelope containing a Golden Ticket solves that problem!) The creative possibilities are endless and the Golden Ticket will surely bring a smile to the face of the recipient.
What the jury decided in the states’ case
On April 15, 2026, the jury found Live Nation and Ticketmaster liable for antitrust violations in the case pursued by the states that stayed in. Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti said the jury found unlawful monopoly maintenance in primary ticketing for major venues, a Live Nation monopoly in large amphitheaters, and unlawful conditioning of artists’ use of company-controlled amphitheaters on their use of Live Nation promotion services.
Skrmetti characterized the verdict by saying, “A jury determined that Live Nation and Ticketmaster are an illegal monopoly.” He also said a breakup was “absolutely on the table.” Those are the attorney general’s descriptions and view of possible relief; the verdict was a liability finding, not a final order specifying remedies. The states’ coalition said remedies and financial penalties would be heard separately.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Rank #3
- SURPRISE CONCERT TICKET: This scratch and reveal card is a very special and fun way to reveal a surprise concert. This personalized gift card can also be kept as a souvenir and can also be used as decoration.
- PERSONALIZED GIFT IDEA: This blank concert ticket can be customized by you. Just fill in the information on the ticket and then stick the scratch off sticker on the circle on the right.
- SCRATCH AND REVEAL: This scratch and reveal gift turns every moment into a surprise—it's a playful, interactive, and unforgettable way to say wow!
- HIGH QUALITY CARD: The concert scratch card is printed on high quality paper with the size of 8.3 inches x 3.9 inches. It also includes a matching gift envelope in which the concert ticket can be inserted.
- MULTIPLE OCCASIONS: It can be used for multiple occasions as a birthday gift, Valentine's day gift, Christmas gift, wedding gift or anniversary gift.
What the proposed judgment says about payments
The DOJ case page listed a proposed final judgment filed June 12, 2026. Its state-specific provisions set out these proposed settlement payments, which the document says resolve specified monetary-relief and civil-penalty claims:
| State | Proposed payment |
|---|---|
| Arkansas | $3,548,637.22 |
| Iowa | $3,000,000 |
| Mississippi | $2,780,037.76 |
| Nebraska | $3,588,759.96 |
| Oklahoma | $4,967,661.87 |
| South Dakota | $677,920 |
These are amounts in a filed proposal, not proof of final approval or payment. The available materials do not establish a later court order entering the judgment.
Rank #4
- 1) Want to create the most realistic concert or event ticket ever? This concert ticket offers a fantastic gift idea that is sure to thrill your partner, parents, and friends.
- 2) Package: You'll get 1 concert ticket, 1 white envelope, and 1 heart-shaped golden scratch-off sticker.
- 3) Size & Material: The concert ticket measures 3.5 x 8 inches (width x length). The ticket is made of high quality thick cardstock paper, which makes the cards durable and easy to write on.
- 4) Surprise your loved ones with an incredible concert ticket, designed to make birthdays, anniversaries, and special occasions even more memorable. By customizing the features, you can create a personalized concert ticket, adding an extra touch of excitement to your surprise experience.
How to read Live Nation’s account of the jury award
Live Nation’s public response said the jury awarded $1.72 per ticket for a limited group of tickets sold at 257 venues—about 20% of total tickets, according to the company. It said the calculation covered fan purchases, excluding brokers, in certain states over five years. These scope descriptions and figures are Live Nation’s characterization, not an independently established final damages calculation in the materials cited here.
Based on that account, Live Nation estimated aggregate single damages below $150 million before trebling, and said it had accrued $280 million toward state damages and civil-penalty claims in connection with the DOJ settlement. The company also said it planned to renew its motion for judgment as a matter of law and challenge the damages testimony. Those statements describe the defendant’s position and reported accounting, not a final court ruling on damages or the motions.
Best Value
- Easily customize your own raffle tickets, auction tickets, carnival tickets, admission tickets and more with templates and designs with Avery Design & Print Online
- Enjoy a clean, professional finish from the micro-perforated design that allows for easy separation and a smooth border around each tear off ticket
- Print beautiful, double-sided designs on matte white printable cardstock paper with a weight of 65 lbs / 176 gsm
- Each sheet of printable cardstock is optimized for laser and inkjet printers, resulting in crisp text, vivid images and smudge-free printing
- Item includes 20 printable sheets with a total of 200 blank 1.75" x 5.5" tickets with tear-away stubs, perfect for diaper raffle tickets, event tickets, fundraisers, ticket invitations and door prizes
What ticket buyers should—and should not—take from the case
The proposed settlement focused on ticketing access, venue choice, exclusivity, service fees and amphitheater booking agreements. If approved and implemented, those provisions could affect the choices available to venues and the way tickets are distributed. But the announcement alone did not establish that venues had gained new marketplace options, that fees had changed, or that competition had increased.
Likewise, the states’ liability verdict did not itself set a final remedy or establish a final consumer refund. The distinction matters to ticket buyers: proposed conduct changes, a jury’s liability findings and an entered remedy are separate legal events. The later remedy orders and the final status of the DOJ settlement would determine what changes, if any, become binding.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
