The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Surat Bench, quashed the reassessment of Harshali Lavishkumar Jain because the fresh notice under section 148 was issued beyond the surviving time available under the Supreme Court’s transitional rules. The decision turned on limitation—not on whether Jain’s Income Declaration Scheme declaration or explanation for a delayed tax payment was valid.
What the ₹50 lakh income-tax case was about
Jain’s appeal concerned assessment year (AY) 2017–18. The ITAT order says she filed her return on 7 November 2017, declaring income of ₹6,88,140. The department received information that she had declared ₹50,00,000 under the Income Declaration Scheme (IDS) 2016 for AY 2012–13 but had not completed the process by submitting Form-4, described in the order as the certificate of final acceptance. The assessment treated ₹50,00,000 as unexplained income under “income from other sources.”
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Jain told the tribunal she had paid the required IDS tax of ₹22,50,000. She said ₹5,62,500 was not credited to the government before the deadline because of a bank technical error, and that the bank had issued a certificate acknowledging the error. Those were her submissions, not findings that the ITAT accepted: the tribunal decided the appeal on limitation and did not rule on the merits of the IDS declaration or the bank-payment explanation. Read the ITAT order.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Why the section 148 notice was held time-barred
The dispute arose during the transition from the former reassessment procedure to the amended procedure. The ITAT applied the Supreme Court’s directions in Union of India v. Ashish Agarwal and its later explanation of surviving time in Union of India v. Rajeev Bansal. In this transition, certain old-regime notices were treated as show-cause notices under section 148A(b). The remaining statutory time then governed completion of the next steps, including issuing a fresh notice under section 148.
#1 Best Overall
The tribunal order records this sequence:
- 30 June 2021: The department issued an original notice under section 148 under the old reassessment regime.
- 25 May 2022: A notice under section 148A(b) was issued under the procedure that followed the Supreme Court’s directions.
- 26 May 2022: Jain replied to the section 148A(b) notice.
- 29 June 2022: The department issued a fresh notice under section 148.
The ITAT held that the 29 June 2022 notice was issued after the surviving period had expired. It therefore held the notice invalid and quashed the reassessment and assessment order. The order reproduces the Supreme Court’s statement in paragraph 113 of Rajeev Bansal: “A reassessment notice issued beyond the surviving time limit will be time- barred.” The tribunal order is the controlling source for this case’s holding and dates. Mint also reported the same chronology and result: Mint’s account of the decision.
What the ruling does—and does not—decide
The ruling is specific to the applicable transition rules and the dates in Jain’s case. It does not establish that every notice issued after an old section 148 notice is invalid, or that a bank’s payment-processing error excuses an incomplete IDS declaration.
Rank #2
- Decided: Whether the fresh section 148 notice was issued within the surviving time available under the transitional framework.
- Not decided: Whether Jain’s IDS declaration was legally complete, whether the disputed payment was made in time, or whether the bank’s explanation would change the tax treatment.
How ordinary reassessment time limits differ from this transition case
The Income Tax Department’s published assessment guidance describes the ordinary sequence: the assessing officer issues a section 148A show-cause notice with information suggesting income escaped assessment, allows the taxpayer to respond, and issues a section 148 notice if proceeding with reassessment. Its summary gives these general limits:
| Amount of alleged escaped income | Section 148A notice | Section 148 notice |
|---|---|---|
| Less than ₹50 lakh | Within three years from the end of the relevant assessment year | Within three years and three months |
| ₹50 lakh or more | Within five years from the end of the relevant assessment year | Within five years and three months |
These are the general periods shown in the department’s guidance, not a substitute for applying the law and exceptions relevant to a particular notice. They do not by themselves calculate the surviving time in a case governed by the Supreme Court’s transition directions. See the Income Tax Department’s assessment guidance.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.What to check if you receive a reassessment notice
A comparison with Jain’s case is useful only after establishing which statutory regime and deadlines apply to your own notice. Gather the documents and dates that determine the sequence:
- The original notice and the section under which it was issued.
- Any section 148A(b) notice, including its date and the date by which a response was requested.
- The date you actually responded, and proof of submission or delivery.
- The date of any later section 148 notice.
- The assessment year, the information or allegation stated in the notice, and the statutory version or transition rules applicable to it.
Those facts can help identify a limitation issue, but Jain’s outcome does not determine another taxpayer’s case. The applicable deadlines depend on the governing law and the individual notice history; a qualified tax professional can review the documents and calculate the relevant period.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- Quick reference learning guide
- Definitions and glossary of terms
- Tax tips, and everything else you need to know about filing
- Common mistakes, understand audits
- Claiming a dependant and more
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →
