If you want income without relying on mortgage REITs, compare property-owning REITs and REIT funds, savings accounts and CDs, bonds and other fixed-income securities, publicly traded business development companies (BDCs), and interval or semi-liquid credit funds. They earn money in different ways and carry different risks: a bank deposit rate, a bond yield, and a fund distribution rate are not interchangeable measures. Choose what to investigate by looking at the source of income, potential losses, liquidity, fees, tax treatment, and total return—not by comparing headline yields alone.
What makes mortgage REIT income different?
Mortgage REITs finance real estate by originating or buying mortgages and mortgage-backed securities, then earning interest on those investments. That differs from an equity REIT, which owns real estate and earns income connected to its properties. Nareit describes mortgage REITs as providing financing for income-producing real estate through mortgages and mortgage-backed securities (MBS): Nareit’s Mortgage REIT sector page.
Mortgage REITs can use borrowed money and derivatives, and their results can be sensitive to borrowing costs, interest rates, credit conditions, and hedging. The SEC says mortgage REITs tend to be more leveraged than REITs focused on properties in its Investor Bulletin: Publicly Traded REITs. A high distribution does not by itself show that income is sustainable or that an investment has performed well.
For perspective, Nareit reported a 15.68% mortgage REIT dividend yield and a -12.35% year-to-date total return as of September 30, 2026; both are sector-level figures attributed to the FTSE Nareit U.S. Real Estate Indexes, not a forecast or a return for any one security. Nareit counted 29 mortgage REITs in those indexes on that date. Nareit’s dated sector statistics show why yield should be considered alongside price movement and total return.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
#1 Best Overall
How do the main alternatives compare?
The table compares the source of income and the main trade-offs. Fees, distribution composition, and comparable total returns depend on the specific security or fund; where the cited guidance does not establish a comparable value, it is identified as not stated rather than estimated.
| Alternative | Income source and exposure | Main risks and exit | Fees, distributions, and return comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Equity REITs and REIT funds | Ownership of commercial property; a mutual fund or ETF can provide exposure to multiple REITs. | Property values, financing, market prices, and interest rates can affect results. Publicly traded REIT shares and funds can fluctuate in price; exchange trading generally allows investors to sell during market hours, but not necessarily at the price they want. | Fund fees and current yield depend on the fund and are not stated by the SEC guidance. REIT distributions are generally treated as ordinary income, but an investor’s tax treatment depends on circumstances. No like-for-like total-return figure is provided here. SEC: Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) |
| Savings accounts and CDs | Interest paid on a deposit; neither provides the same real-estate exposure as a REIT. | Check the current APY, CD maturity, early-withdrawal terms, and applicable deposit protections. A CD’s access and penalty terms differ from a savings account’s. Rates and terms should be checked with the provider. | Current product rates and a comparable investment total return are not stated in the cited SEC guidance. The SEC names savings accounts and CDs as alternatives investors may find more attractive when their rates rise. SEC: Investor Bulletin: Publicly Traded REITs |
| Bonds and other fixed income | Interest payments and, depending on the security, repayment of principal; exposure is to the issuer rather than to mortgage REIT assets. | Assess issuer credit quality, maturity, duration, call terms, and liquidity. Credit problems can impair repayment; market prices can change as rates and credit spreads move. | No current, like-for-like bond yield or total-return comparison is stated in the cited guidance. Expenses and distribution composition vary by security or fund. |
| Publicly traded BDCs | Debt and equity investments in small and medium-sized companies, rather than mortgage assets. | Borrower defaults, uncertain valuations of private holdings, leverage, fees, and market-price fluctuations can affect investors. Shares can be sold on the market, but the price may differ from underlying portfolio values. | A BDC distribution can include return of capital; it should not be treated as a guaranteed yield. Fees and comparable total-return figures depend on the BDC. SEC: Publicly Traded Business Development Companies (BDCs): Investor Bulletin |
| Interval or semi-liquid credit funds | Credit investments that may include less-liquid assets; the specific portfolio depends on the fund. | Investors generally cannot exit on demand. Repurchase offers are periodic and may be limited, so an investor may receive only part of the amount requested or have to wait for another offer. | Fund-specific fees, distribution composition, and comparable total returns are not stated in the cited guidance. Review the fund’s prospectus and repurchase terms. SEC: Investor Bulletin: Interval Funds |
Which alternative changes the exposure most?
Equity REITs and diversified REIT funds
These retain real-estate exposure but shift it from mortgages and MBS toward property ownership. The SEC says investors can access REITs directly or through mutual funds and ETFs; publicly traded REITs may also be common stock, preferred stock, or debt. A fund can spread exposure across holdings, but diversification does not eliminate real-estate or market risk. Check its sector mix, fees, and current yield rather than assuming every REIT fund behaves alike. SEC: Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)
Rank #2
Savings accounts and CDs
These replace investment exposure with deposit interest, so they are not a way to keep the same real-estate exposure with a different wrapper. Compare the offered APY with the account terms: for a CD, include the maturity date and early-withdrawal penalty in the comparison. The SEC notes that savings accounts and CDs may become more attractive alternatives to REIT dividends when their rates rise; actual rates and terms change, so check current provider information before deciding. SEC: Investor Bulletin: Publicly Traded REITs
Bonds and other fixed-income securities
Fixed income is not one uniform alternative. An issuer’s ability to pay, the time until maturity, duration, call provisions, and the ease of selling all matter. A bond’s stated interest rate or yield is not directly comparable with a REIT fund’s distribution rate: the cash-flow terms and risks differ, and a bond can lose market value before maturity. No current bond yield comparison is included here.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Publicly traded BDCs
BDCs shift the underlying credit exposure from real estate to smaller companies. Review the borrowers and portfolio quality, how private investments are valued, the BDC’s leverage and fees, and how its distributions are funded. The SEC cautions that BDC distributions may include return of capital; a payout is not proof of equivalent investment income or a guaranteed investor yield. SEC: Publicly Traded Business Development Companies (BDCs): Investor Bulletin
Interval and semi-liquid private-credit funds
These funds may hold less-liquid assets while offering scheduled repurchases instead of daily exchange trading. The SEC says interval-fund offers are generally made every three, six, or twelve months; shareholders may have to wait as long as twelve months for another offer, and an offer may be limited. Read the fund’s repurchase terms before investing, including what happens if requests exceed the amount the fund will repurchase. SEC: Investor Bulletin: Interval Funds
How should income investors compare yield and risk?
- Identify what pays the income. Determine whether cash comes from property operations, mortgage interest, deposit interest, bond payments, or company lending and equity investments.
- Check the risks behind the payment. For a fund or security, look at interest-rate and spread sensitivity, leverage, borrower or issuer credit quality, and any reliance on hedging or hard-to-value assets. For deposits, check the account’s rate and terms.
- Compare access to your money. A publicly traded share can be sold in the market, though its price can move. A CD has a maturity and may impose an early-withdrawal penalty. An interval fund can restrict how much is repurchased and when.
- Read fees and distribution composition. Review fund expenses and reports, and distinguish investment income from any return of capital. A distribution can remain high even when the market price falls or total return is negative.
- Compare total return over the same dates. Include both income and price changes for the same holding period. Do not set a bank APY beside a fund distribution rate as if both measured the same return or risk.
- Check tax treatment and personal constraints. REIT distributions are generally treated as ordinary income, according to Investor.gov; individual tax outcomes vary. Consider liquidity needs, time horizon, and tolerance for credit and market losses.
What does private-credit market context tell investors?
Private credit is broader than BDCs and retail-accessible funds, so market-size figures should not be read as the amount an individual fund holds or the income it can pay. The Federal Reserve’s May 2026 Financial Stability Report said private-credit loans totaled $1.4 trillion, or 10% of total U.S. debt, using its latest data from the second half of 2025. In the report’s 2026 snapshot, perpetual-life BDCs had $306 billion in gross assets and $161 billion in net assets; interval funds had $119 billion in gross assets and $80 billion in net assets. These figures describe those vehicle categories, not publicly traded BDCs as a whole. Federal Reserve Board, Financial Stability Report, May 2026: Funding Risks
The same report described rising redemption requests for semi-liquid private-credit vehicles through the first quarter of 2026 and said many managers capped redemptions. That is time-bounded market context, not a prediction about every fund, but it illustrates why periodic repurchase rights are not equivalent to on-demand liquidity. Federal Reserve Board, Financial Stability Report, May 2026: Funding Risks
Quick Recap
What to check before replacing a mortgage REIT
- Read the prospectus, annual report, or account terms for the specific investment, including portfolio holdings, leverage, fees, and liquidity provisions.
- For REIT funds, inspect sector allocation and whether holdings are property-owning REITs, mortgage REITs, or a mix.
- For BDCs, examine portfolio credit quality, valuation policies, borrowing, expenses, and distribution composition.
- For interval funds, understand the offer schedule, limits, and how unfilled repurchase requests are handled.
- Compare total return over matching dates instead of selecting solely by the largest quoted distribution.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
