Some wrestling cards have drawn strong prices, but “worth money” depends on the exact issue, its condition, and the sale being compared. A standout example is the 1982 Wrestling All-Stars Series A #2 Hulk Hogan: PSA records an $8,540 sale for a PSA 8 copy at Heritage Auctions on September 19, 2026. The 1985 Wrestling All Stars set also includes several notable cards, led in Midpoint’s guide by Andre the Giant #46. These are research candidates, not a definitive ranking of the most valuable wrestling cards.
How to read this list
The first card below has a documented auction result. The remaining 15 are notable issues from the 1985 Wrestling All Stars checklist, with guide examples for the five leading names and checklist-level candidates for the rest. A guide estimate is not a completed sale, and a card’s value cannot be inferred from the wrestler’s fame alone.
Midpoint’s estimates below were accessed October 4, 2026. Its PSA 10 and raw figures are separate guide values, not guaranteed proceeds or prices established by one specific transaction. “Raw” means not professionally graded. PSA population counts and census data are also changeable, not fixed measures of scarcity.
16 wrestling cards collectors should check
1. 1982 Wrestling All-Stars Series A #2 Hulk Hogan
Identify the exact issue as the Series A #2 card; “Hulk Hogan #2” by itself is not enough to distinguish it. PSA records a PSA 8 copy sold through Heritage Auctions for $8,540 on September 19, 2026. PSA’s CardFacts snapshot accessed October 4, 2026 listed 19 PSA 9 examples and 79 PSA 8 examples. Its grade table separately showed a $4,050 most-recent-price field for PSA 9 and an $8,401 field for PSA 8; these fields are distinct from the cited Heritage sale and should not be treated as interchangeable. The census can change as cards are graded or discovered.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
#1 Best Overall
- 4 cards per pack. 7 packs per box. 3 exclusive diamond plate refractors per box.
- Topps Chrome WWE combines the signature shine and technology of Chrome with the larger-than-life personas of WWE. Through a series of groundbreaking subsets, 2026 Topps Chrome WWE builds a dynamic checklist highlighting current headliners, emerging talent, and legendary icons who defined the ring.
- Beyond the base checklist, the product expands with an exciting slate of themed subsets that capture WWE’s biggest moments and most unforgettable personas. Collectors can also pursue a wide spectrum of refractor parallels across the rainbow—from classic color variations to rare, low-numbered editions.
- Fan-favorite Chrome inserts return, including Helix, Feel the Pop, and Let's Go, alongside new WWE-specific debuts such as Signalz and Gamut.
- Topps Chrome is one of the most iconic chromium trading card brands in The Hobby. Renowned for its vibrant refractors, expansive rainbow chases, and premium autograph content, Topps Chrome has helped define modern collecting across multiple sports.
2. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #46 Andre the Giant
Midpoint listed a $4,200 PSA 10 estimate and a $16.25 raw estimate. Those very different figures illustrate why a top-grade guide value is not a reasonable stand-in for an ungraded card.
3. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #1 Hulk Hogan
Midpoint listed a $3,547 PSA 10 estimate and a $45.94 raw estimate.
4. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #2 Ric Flair
Midpoint listed a $2,122 PSA 10 estimate and a $38.76 raw estimate.
Rank #2
- 8 Cards per Pack, 6 Packs per Box. 10 Exclusive X-Fractors per Box.
- Topps Chrome WWE combines the signature shine and technology of Chrome with the larger-than-life personas of WWE. Through a series of groundbreaking subsets, 2026 Topps Chrome WWE builds a dynamic checklist highlighting current headliners, emerging talent, and legendary icons who defined the ring.
- Beyond the base checklist, the product expands with an exciting slate of themed subsets that capture WWE’s biggest moments and most unforgettable personas. Collectors can also pursue a wide spectrum of refractor parallels across the rainbow—from classic color variations to rare, low-numbered editions.
- Fan-favorite Chrome inserts return, including Helix, Feel the Pop, and Let's Go, alongside new WWE-specific debuts such as Signalz and Gamut.
- Topps Chrome is one of the most iconic chromium trading card brands in The Hobby. Renowned for its vibrant refractors, expansive rainbow chases, and premium autograph content, Topps Chrome has helped define modern collecting across multiple sports.
5. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #11 Kerry Von Erich
Midpoint listed a $1,053 PSA 10 estimate and a $16.63 raw estimate.
6. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #49 Masked Superstar
Midpoint listed a $1,031 PSA 10 estimate and a $16.20 raw estimate.
7. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #14 Missing Link
This is another named candidate in the set checklist. The available material does not establish a comparable grade-specific estimate or realized sale for it, so no dollar value is assigned here.
Rank #3
- Includes 12 Cards per Pack, 4 Packs per Box
- The stunning Dazzlers insert makes a triumphant return featuring some of AEW’s biggest names. Collect the Blaster Exclusive Orange parallel, falling one in every six packs.
- Build your own AEW-branded deck of playing cards! The Double or Nothing Playing cards 54-card insert set includes 2-10’s (36 wrestlers), J-K’s (12 wrestlers), Aces (4 wrestlers) and Jokers (2 wrestlers/Crew) and is printed on 12-pt. playing card stock with playing card coating.
- Finish It features some of AEW’s best and most notable finishing moves like Toni Storm’s “Storm Zero” and Mariah May’s “Mayday.” Each card will feature the finishing moves for two wrestlers on a unique lenticular substrate.
- Neon Monikers features a prominent and colorful design and some of the most noteworthy nicknames in AEW. Look for the Blaster Exclusive Red parallel.
8. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #18 Carlos Colon
Midpoint’s checklist names this card, but the available material does not establish a comparable grade-specific estimate or completed-sale price.
9. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #12 Jimmy Valiant
This checklist candidate does not have a comparable grade-specific estimate or completed-sale figure established in the available material.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
10. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #47 The Fabulous Ones
The checklist identifies the card, but no comparable grade-specific estimate or completed sale is established here.
Rank #4
- Configuration: 6 Cards Per Pack. 6 Packs Per Box
- 2026 Panini MLW Ring Royalty – Collect the latest Panini trading card release celebrating Major League Wrestling and its roster of wrestling stars and legends
- Major League Wrestling Cards – Discover collectible cards featuring MLW wrestlers, memorable moments and exciting pro wrestling content
- Chase Autographs, Inserts & Parallels – Search for collectible autograph cards, colorful parallels and special insert cards throughout the set
- Great for Wrestling Fans – Perfect for MLW fans, wrestling card collectors, Panini collectors and sports memorabilia enthusiasts
11. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #37 Mil Mascaras
This is a checklist candidate; a comparable grade-specific estimate or realized price is not established here.
12. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #8 Paul Orndorff
The card appears among the set’s named candidates, but no comparable grade-specific estimate or completed sale is established here.
13. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #43 Gino Hernandez
This checklist candidate has no comparable grade-specific estimate or realized sale established in the available figures.
14. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #39 Jimmy Garvin
Midpoint’s checklist names the issue, but a comparable grade-specific estimate or completed sale is not established here.
15. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #20 Tommy Rich
This is a checklist candidate, not a card with a comparable grade-specific value established here.
16. 1985 Wrestling All Stars #5 The Iron Sheik
The checklist includes this card, but no comparable grade-specific estimate or realized sale is established here.
Quick Recap
How to estimate a card you own
- Identify the exact issue. Record the year, set, series if applicable, card number, subject, and any variation. Similar names or numbers can refer to different cards.
- Assess condition before comparing prices. Look for corner wear, creases, surface damage, centering, and other condition issues. Keep raw-card comparisons separate from professionally graded examples.
- Find completed sales for the same card and similar grade. Prefer multiple recent transactions over asking prices. Record the venue and date; sales from different periods or venues can vary materially.
- Use population data as context, not a price formula. PSA cautions that its Condition Census is a work in progress and can contain errors or omissions; counts change as cards are graded or discovered. A population figure does not by itself prove scarcity or predict a future price.
Sources and limits
- PSA CardFacts: 1982 Wrestling All-Stars Series A #2 Hulk Hogan provides grade-specific fields, population figures, and auction history; accessed October 4, 2026.
- PSA certification 14269959 identifies the cited PSA 8 card and its Heritage Auctions sale on September 19, 2026.
- Midpoint: 1985 Wrestling All Stars Checklist & Card Prices supplies guide estimates and checklist examples; accessed October 4, 2026.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →
