What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
Short version: PayPal-owned Honey remains available, but affiliate marketers and creators accuse the extension of replacing their tracking identifiers with PayPal’s after a shopper had already arrived through a creator’s link. The allegations are being litigated—not proven findings of fraud or deception. A November 2025 dismissal concerned an earlier complaint; plaintiffs filed a Second Amended Complaint in January 2026, and the latest located order allowed those claims to proceed past PayPal’s motion to dismiss.
What Honey is supposed to do
Honey is a free browser extension and shopping service. On supported stores, it can test coupon codes at checkout, show price information and tracking, and offer PayPal Rewards points on eligible purchases. Honey says it supports more than 30,000 sites, a company marketing claim rather than an independently audited count.
- Install the extension in a supported browser.
- Visit a participating merchant and activate Honey when its prompt appears.
- Honey tests available coupon codes or displays shopping information.
- If the purchase qualifies, the user may receive rewards points under the applicable terms.
Honey’s terms say the service does not charge users, but they also say coupons, offers, rewards and third-party product information may be unavailable, incomplete or inaccurate. Honey’s U.S. help material says 1,000 points can be redeemed for a $10 gift card from participating stores, subject to terms; its FAQ says rewards transactions generally become pending within two to 14 days, although timing varies. See Honey’s terms, help page and FAQ.
PayPal acquired Honey for $4 billion in 2020, according to the court’s description of the transaction (November 2025 order).
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREEClear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEFix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →#1 Best Overall
How affiliate attribution normally works
A creator may publish a merchant link containing Creator A’s affiliate identifier. When a reader clicks, the merchant or affiliate network records that referral in a cookie or another tracking system. If the reader buys within the attribution window, Creator A may receive a commission.
For illustration only, a 5% commission on a $200 order would be $10. The actual rate, attribution rules and eligibility depend on the merchant and network.
What plaintiffs allege Honey did
The Second Amended Complaint describes an alleged “Secret Tab” and calls the conduct “cookie stuffing.” Plaintiffs claim Honey could create a hidden tab, iframe, refresh or similar request to the merchant, generate a new referral, and replace an existing creator or publisher identifier with PayPal’s. They further allege this could happen when Honey found no usable coupon, or after a user merely interacted with or dismissed a prompt. These are allegations in the complaint, not judicial findings.
The alleged effect is an attribution change: the extension would receive credit for a sale that plaintiffs say was initiated by someone else. The complaint also alleges inadequate disclosure to users, creators, merchants or affiliate networks. Honey’s current Chrome listing, however, says merchants may pay Honey affiliate commissions and that Honey shares those commissions with users as rewards (Chrome Web Store listing). Whether that disclosure addresses the specific alleged behavior is unresolved.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Who could be affected?
Creators and publishers
The principal alleged injury is lost affiliate revenue. A creator may have generated the shopping visit yet lose the commission if another identifier becomes the credited last click.
Merchants and affiliate networks
The allegations raise questions about whether merchants or networks paid commissions where Honey did not generate the original demand, and whether any conduct complied with network contracts, attribution rules or “stand-down” provisions.
Consumers
Consumers may still receive a coupon or reward, so the direct financial harm is less clear. Separate questions concern whether users understood Honey’s commission relationships, what shopping data the extension processes, and whether extension activity affects offers or reward eligibility. The allegations do not establish that Honey universally charged users higher prices.
What the court has—and has not—decided
The consolidated case is In re PayPal Honey Browser Extension Litigation, Northern District of California case 5:24-cv-09470-BLF. The district court’s case page is here.
| Date | Procedural event | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| December 29, 2024 | Case filed | Litigation began. |
| November 7, 2025 | Motion to compel arbitration denied | The dispute remained in court; this was not a liability ruling. (order) |
| November 21, 2025 | First Amended Complaint dismissed | The court found pleading problems, including traceability and whether plaintiffs adequately pleaded entitlement to commissions. (order) |
| January 5, 2026 | Second Amended Complaint filed | Plaintiffs revised their allegations and added specific contractual provisions. |
| Latest order located by August 16, 2026 | PayPal’s later motion to dismiss denied | The pleaded claims survived that procedural challenge; the court did not find Honey liable. (order) |
The revised claims include theories under the federal Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, California’s Comprehensive Computer Data Access and Fraud Act and Unfair Competition Law, Washington’s Consumer Protection Act, unjust enrichment and interference. A denial of dismissal is not summary judgment, a trial verdict or a settlement.
PayPal’s position
In its litigation arguments, PayPal contends that any lost commission resulted from ordinary last-click attribution rather than wrongful conduct; that plaintiffs did not show a contractual right to the commissions; and that users authorized the extension through applicable terms and permissions. Those are defenses, not admissions or established facts. No final finding of liability appears in the materials cited above.
Honey’s current product and data disclosures
The Chrome listing showed version 19.4.0, updated June 5, 2026, and more than 17 million members at that time. Honey’s help page says the extension supports Chrome, Safari, Firefox and Opera. Product figures and labels can change, so they should be checked before publication. Honey now generally refers to PayPal Rewards rather than consistently using the older Honey Gold name.
Honey’s current U.S. privacy statement says its services may process identifiers, shopping and usage information, transaction values and returns, preferred merchants or categories, internet and network activity, and inferences about shopping preferences. It describes rewards as a financial-incentive program and estimates the value of a California user’s personal information at $15 for notice purposes (privacy statement).
That is different from what an extension technically can read or modify on a supported page. Honey’s older data-and-privacy explainer says it checks shopping sites, observes checkout activity for commission tracking and does not sell user information, but it was last updated in 2019 (older explainer). The current privacy statement should control your understanding.
Should you keep or remove Honey?
Keeping it may make sense if
- You value automatic coupon testing, price tools or rewards.
- You accept the extension’s permissions, disclosures and data practices.
- You understand that discounts and rewards are not guaranteed.
Removing it may make sense if
- You are uncomfortable with the affiliate-attribution allegations.
- You want to minimize shopping-page access or shopping-history collection.
- You want to avoid any possibility that a creator’s referral is displaced.
If you decide to remove it, uninstall Honey from every browser, disable related Honey or PayPal shopping add-ons, review extension permissions, check PayPal/Honey account connections and rewards settings, and look for other coupon or cashback extensions that may also affect attribution. Browser menu names vary by version, so use your browser’s current extension-management instructions.
Practical guidance for creators and affiliate marketers
- Test the complete path: click your affiliate link, install or interact with Honey, dismiss its prompt, apply a coupon, activate rewards and complete checkout.
- Repeat across browsers, extension versions, merchants, mobile and desktop, and different attribution windows.
- Preserve timestamps, browser and extension versions, screenshots, network logs and affiliate-network reports.
- Review merchant and network contracts for cookie-stuffing, toolbar, forced-click and stand-down provisions.
- Ask the relevant network to interpret an attribution change before making public accusations.
A changed commission does not by itself prove deception. Last-click rules, network deduplication, merchant overrides, blocked cookies, ad blockers, competing extensions, version changes and legitimate Honey reward activation can produce similar observations.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Alternatives and trade-offs
| Option | Primary use | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Rakuten | Cashback and shopping portals | Current rates, payout rules, merchant coverage and attribution behavior. |
| Capital One Shopping | Coupons, price comparison and alerts | Permissions, affiliate disclosures, terms and supported stores; it is not proven free of attribution concerns. |
| Microsoft Edge shopping tools | Built-in coupons and price comparison | Regional and account availability; requires using Edge. |
| Manual research | Merchant coupons, email offers, price-history tools and direct comparison | More time, but no extra coupon-extension permissions. |
No alternative should be described as legally safer without separate evidence. Check each service’s privacy policy, permissions, affiliate disclosures, merchant coverage and reward terms.
PC Slower Than It Used to Be?
A free scan shows the junk files, broken settings and background clutter dragging Windows down - then fixes them in one click.Free scan · Windows 10 & 11Crashes, No Sound, or Screen Glitches?
Random freezes, missing sound and display glitches usually trace back to one bad driver. Find and replace yours safely.Free scan · under a minuteWhat remains unresolved
- How often the alleged behavior occurred and which merchants or networks were affected.
- Whether Honey received commissions when another affiliate generated the original visit.
- What internal rules, contracts and disclosures applied at each point in time.
- Whether behavior varied by extension version, merchant, browser or user action.
- How any disputed commissions should be measured.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has a court ruled that Honey committed fraud?
No. The latest located order allowed the pleaded claims to proceed past a motion to dismiss. It did not determine that Honey committed fraud or owe damages.
Is Honey still available?
Yes. Honey continues to be offered through its website, supported browsers and the Chrome Web Store, although versions, membership counts and features can change.
Does uninstalling Honey prove a creator will receive every commission?
No. Attribution also depends on merchant rules, affiliate-network settings, cookies, competing extensions and the attribution window.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
