Through September 30, 2026, SCHD beat the reported S&P 500 return over one year but trailed it over five years. Schwab reported a 23.32% one-year market-price total return and a 9.47% five-year annualized market-price return for SCHD. Kiplinger’s comparison table showed 15.7% for the S&P 500 over one year and 13.8% annualized over five years. SCHD’s separately reported yield supplied cash distributions, but it is already reflected in total-return figures when distributions are reinvested; it is not an extra percentage to add on top.
The comparison in one table
The result depends on the horizon and on which return measure is being compared. Schwab’s figures are for SCHD total returns through September 30, 2026, with the market-price series used for the headline comparison. Kiplinger’s table reports the S&P 500 index return for the same ending date.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
| Investment or series | One-year return to Sept. 30, 2026 | Five-year return to Sept. 30, 2026 | How the figure is labeled |
|---|---|---|---|
| SCHD market price | 23.32% | 9.47% annualized | Schwab total return; market-price performance |
| SCHD net asset value (NAV) | 23.36% | 9.48% annualized | Schwab total return; NAV performance |
| Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index | 23.48% | 9.56% annualized | Index SCHD is designed to track, before fund fees and expenses |
| S&P 500 | 15.7% | 13.8% annualized | Kiplinger table using the S&P 500 index return |
On the published rounded numbers, SCHD’s one-year market-price result was about 7.6 percentage points higher than the S&P 500’s. Over five years, the S&P 500’s annualized result was about 4.3 percentage points higher than SCHD’s. Those are simple subtractions of the reported figures, not a claim that the two sources use identical calculation systems. SCHD’s number is a fund market-price return; the S&P 500 number is an index return.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
How to read the one-year and five-year figures
One year is a period return
The 23.32% SCHD figure describes the total return over the one-year period ending September 30, 2026. It includes the effect of distributions under Schwab’s stated reinvestment convention. The 15.7% S&P 500 figure covers the same one-year endpoint in Kiplinger’s table. Because both figures end on September 30, the comparison avoids mixing different market conditions at the endpoints.
#1 Best Overall
Five years is annualized, not cumulative
SCHD’s 9.47% and the S&P 500’s 13.8% are annualized five-year returns. They describe the average yearly compounded rate over five years, not the total percentage gain from the first day to the last. A 9.47% annualized rate cannot be treated as a 9.47% cumulative five-year gain, and it should not be multiplied by five as though compounding did not exist.
Annualization makes different holding periods easier to compare, but it can hide the uneven path that produced the average. Two investments can have the same annualized figure while experiencing very different calendar-year gains and losses. The published five-year comparison tells you which compounded rate was higher; it does not explain every interim year.
Market price, NAV and index returns are different objects
An ETF has a net asset value based on the value of its portfolio and a market price set by buyers and sellers on the exchange. Schwab’s NAV return for SCHD was 23.36% over one year and 9.48% annualized over five years, slightly different from the market-price figures of 23.32% and 9.47%. The difference is normal for an exchange-traded fund and can arise from premiums, discounts, bid-ask spreads and trading conditions.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problems2Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitches3Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsThe Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index, which SCHD seeks to track before fees and expenses, returned 23.48% over one year and 9.56% annualized over five years. An index return does not deduct a fund’s operating expenses. The S&P 500 is likewise an index that cannot be purchased directly as an unmanaged index, so comparing an index return with an ETF market-price return requires care.
Rank #2
- Ideal for Gifting
- Ideal for a bookworm
- Compact for travelling
What SCHD’s yield actually bought
Two yields, two dates, two definitions
Schwab reported a 3.00% trailing-12-month distribution yield as of August 31, 2026. This is a backward-looking measure based on distributions paid during the previous 12 months. Schwab also reported a 3.34% 30-day SEC yield as of October 9, 2026. The SEC yield is a standardized estimate based on the fund’s recent income and expenses over a 30-day period.
Neither figure is a promise of future income. They differ because they use different periods and methods, and they were measured on different dates. A yield quoted without its definition and date can make two non-comparable numbers look interchangeable.
The listed 2026 payments
Schwab’s distribution history lists these 2026 income payments:
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →| Payment date | Income distribution per share | Capital-gain classification shown |
|---|---|---|
| March 25, 2026 | $0.2569 | Zero short- and long-term capital gain |
| June 24, 2026 | $0.2525 | Zero short- and long-term capital gain |
| September 23, 2026 | $0.2665 | Zero short- and long-term capital gain |
| Three listed payments | $0.7759 | Not a full-calendar-year total |
The three listed payments add to $0.7759 per share. A fourth-quarter payment is not included in that sum, so it cannot be described as SCHD’s complete 2026 distribution. The table is useful for showing the cash amounts and dates, not for forecasting the next payment.
Why you must not add the yield to the return
Total return combines changes in the investment’s value with distributions. Schwab’s performance presentation assumes reinvestment of dividends and distributions where applicable. Therefore, adding 3.00% or 3.34% to SCHD’s 23.32% one-year total return would count the income twice.
The yield answers an income question: how much recent distribution income did the fund produce relative to a specified price or value? Total return answers a performance question: how did an investment perform when distributions and price changes are combined under the stated convention? The one-year and five-year comparisons already use total-return figures. The separately reported yield helps describe the form of the return, but it does not explain the entire difference between SCHD and the S&P 500.
Why SCHD can diverge from the S&P 500
A dividend-screened strategy rather than a broad-market replica
SCHD’s stated objective is to track, before fees and expenses, the total return of the Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index. Schwab describes the index as focused on dividend quality and sustainability, using financial ratios to select companies with fundamental strength relative to their peers. The fund is passively managed, but “passive” describes how it follows its index; it does not mean the portfolio has the same holdings or sector weights as the S&P 500.
The S&P 500 represents a broad large-cap U.S. equity universe. SCHD’s dividend requirement can leave out companies that do not pay dividends and can give greater weight to mature businesses with established payout policies. When growth-oriented, non-dividend-paying or low-yielding companies lead the market, the broad index can pull ahead. When dividend-paying companies and the factors associated with them are favored, SCHD can lead for a period such as the reported one-year window.
Rank #4
Income is only one component of an equity return
A stock’s total return comes from both distributions and changes in its market value. A higher distribution yield does not automatically produce a higher total return. A company can distribute cash while its share price lags, or retain more earnings and produce stronger price appreciation without paying a large dividend. The five-year figures illustrate this distinction: SCHD’s income-oriented structure did not prevent the S&P 500 from posting the higher annualized total return.
Costs and the difference between the fund and its benchmark
Schwab reports a 0.060% total expense ratio for SCHD and 102 holdings as of October 12, 2026. The expense ratio is deducted from fund assets and therefore affects the return investors receive relative to the tracked index. The Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index’s 23.48% one-year and 9.56% five-year annualized figures are pre-fund-fee index results, while SCHD’s NAV results are after the fund’s operating expenses and tracking effects.
Even a small expense ratio compounds over time, but it is not the only source of difference. Sampling, portfolio rebalancing, trading costs, tax effects inside the fund and the timing of distributions can all contribute to tracking variation. The market-price return adds the possibility that the ETF trades temporarily above or below NAV.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
Risks that matter when the yield is the attraction
- Distributions can change. Schwab warns that portfolio companies may reduce or stop paying dividends. A trailing yield is historical evidence, not a contractual coupon.
- Dividend restrictions can hurt relative performance. A dividend-focused fund may underperform a fund without that restriction, particularly when non-dividend-paying or lower-yielding companies drive the market.
- Principal fluctuates. SCHD owns equities, so its share price and NAV can fall. Cash distributions do not eliminate market risk.
- Market price can differ from NAV. An ETF share can trade above or below the value of the underlying holdings, especially during volatile or illiquid markets.
- Past performance is not a forecast. Schwab’s disclosure states: “Past performance is no guarantee of future results.” The one-year lead does not establish that SCHD will beat the S&P 500 next year, and the five-year lag does not establish that it will continue to lag.
How to use this comparison for a portfolio decision
Start with the role, not the recent winner
Ask whether the desired role is broad U.S. large-cap exposure, a dividend-screened equity allocation, or a source of potentially regular cash distributions. SCHD is designed for the second description. It is not designed to replicate the S&P 500, so choosing it solely because of the one-year result changes the portfolio’s exposure rather than simply selecting a cheaper version of the same index.
Best Value
- It can be a gift option
- Comes with secure packaging
- Helpful in various ways
Match the return measure to the question
- For a trading-experience question, examine market-price returns and the effect of premiums, discounts and spreads.
- For an underlying-portfolio question, examine NAV returns and tracking relative to the Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index.
- For a long-term compounding question, use annualized multi-year total returns and keep the annualized label attached.
- For an income question, identify whether the quoted number is a trailing distribution yield or a 30-day SEC yield, then record its date.
Check whether cash is being taken or reinvested
An investor withdrawing distributions experiences a different cash-flow pattern from one who reinvests every payment. Schwab’s published total-return figures assume reinvestment where applicable, so an account taking cash will not match the same share-count path. The economic total return concept still includes the distributions, but the investor’s balance and future income depend on what happens to the cash after it is paid.
Use a common date when comparing alternatives
Market results can change substantially when one endpoint is moved. The figures here are aligned at September 30, 2026 for the performance comparison. The yield figures are not aligned to that date: the trailing distribution yield is from August 31 and the SEC yield is from October 9. Keeping those dates visible prevents an income statistic measured in October from being read as though it were part of the September performance calculation.
A practical checklist before buying or reallocating
- Define whether the objective is broad-market exposure, dividend-focused exposure, current income or a combination.
- Read the latest fund profile and confirm the expense ratio, holdings and index objective rather than relying on a historical quote.
- Identify the yield type and date; do not compare a trailing distribution yield directly with a 30-day SEC yield.
- Review total returns with distributions included and note whether the source reports market price or NAV.
- Check the ETF’s trading price against NAV and consider bid-ask spreads before placing an order.
- Decide in advance whether distributions will be reinvested or taken as cash, since that choice changes the account’s path.
- Assess concentration, sector exposure and the possibility that a dividend-paying requirement excludes future market leaders.
- Consider taxes, account type, time horizon and risk capacity; a headline yield does not determine after-tax or risk-adjusted results.
The bottom line on what the yield delivered
SCHD’s yield delivered identifiable cash income: Schwab reported a 3.00% trailing-12-month distribution yield at August 31, 2026, a 3.34% 30-day SEC yield at October 9, and three listed 2026 payments totaling $0.7759 per share through September. That income was part of the fund’s total-return experience when reinvested, not a bonus to layer onto the 23.32% one-year result.
The performance record is therefore mixed rather than contradictory. SCHD led the reported S&P 500 return over one year, while the S&P 500 led by roughly 4.3 percentage points a year on the reported five-year annualized comparison. The most useful conclusion is not that one fund permanently wins, but that a dividend-screened strategy buys a particular income and quality profile in exchange for exposure that can diverge—sometimes positively and sometimes negatively—from the broad U.S. market.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
