Some links on this page are affiliate links: if you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
A loan modification changes your existing mortgage; refinancing replaces it with a new loan. If your regular payment is unaffordable, contact your current servicer promptly to ask about assistance and the options available for your loan. A refinance may help if you qualify for a new mortgage with manageable terms, but it generally involves lender approval and fees. The right choice depends on your finances, loan, and the written terms offered—not on the label alone.
At a glance
| Name | Best for | Key spec | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loan modification | Homeowners asking their current servicer for help because the existing payment is unaffordable | Changes terms of the existing mortgage; an offer may change the rate or repayment period, or address missed payments | November 2026 |
| Refinance | Homeowners who can qualify for a new mortgage whose terms suit their needs | A new loan pays off and replaces the existing mortgage; fees and lender qualification generally apply | November 2026 |
What is the difference between a loan modification and refinancing?
A modification changes the terms of the mortgage you already have, while a refinance is a new mortgage that pays off the old one. That distinction affects whom you contact, whether you must qualify for a new loan, and how to compare the costs and long-term consequences.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
| Decision point | Loan modification | Refinance |
|---|---|---|
| What changes | The terms of your current mortgage. Depending on the offer, the interest rate, repayment period, or treatment of principal and missed payments may change. | A new mortgage replaces your current one. |
| Who to contact | Your current mortgage servicer—the company handling your loan payments and account. | A lender offering a new mortgage. You apply and generally must qualify. |
| How a payment could fall | The servicer may change loan terms, such as the rate or repayment period. The result depends on the offer. | A lower rate, a longer repayment term, or both may lower the monthly payment. |
| Costs and eligibility | The servicer reviews your situation and available loss-mitigation options. Eligibility and terms depend on your loan and circumstances. | You must meet the lender’s requirements for the new loan. Refinancing usually includes fees. |
| Important trade-off | A longer repayment period or adding missed payments to the balance may mean paying for longer or owing more overall. | A lower payment achieved by extending the term can mean paying for longer; fees also affect the value of the change. |
The CFPB’s explanation of mortgage modifications describes possible changes such as extending the repayment period, reducing the interest rate, or forbearing or reducing principal. Not every borrower will be offered each type of change. A refinance, by contrast, requires a lender to make a new loan; the CFPB’s mortgage-payment guidance notes that refinancing can involve fees and that a longer term can be one reason for a lower payment.
What is a mortgage loan modification?
A mortgage loan modification is an agreement with your existing servicer to change one or more terms of the current loan. It is not a second mortgage and it does not automatically replace the original loan. Depending on the proposal, the servicer could alter the interest rate, extend the repayment period, or address principal and missed payments through the structure of the modified loan. The CFPB describes forbearing or reducing principal as possible mechanisms, but an individual offer may use only some of them.
Popular on Amazon
- Ideal for Gifting
- Ideal for a bookworm
- Compact for travelling
The servicer reviews the circumstances and the loss-mitigation programs available for that particular loan. A borrower may need to complete an assistance application and provide information about the hardship, income, expenses, and assets. The servicer’s evaluation, rather than a general internet calculator, determines what terms are actually available. Ask for the decision and all proposed terms in writing.
A modification can reduce the payment enough to make the home affordable, but a smaller payment is not the same as a smaller total obligation. Extending the term means payments continue for more months. If missed amounts are added to the balance, the amount on which interest is calculated or the eventual payoff amount may be higher. Ask the servicer to show the new balance, the scheduled payoff date, and how any deferred or unpaid sums will be handled.
Some modification paths use a trial plan before permanent terms are finalized. Treat the trial as a separate stage: confirm the amount due, the due dates, how payments must be made, and what happens after the final trial payment. Keep the written plan and proof of every payment. Do not assume that a trial payment is the permanent payment or that making trial payments by itself resolves every account issue.
What is refinancing?
Refinancing means applying for a new mortgage that pays off the existing mortgage. You work with a lender, submit an application, and generally must satisfy that lender’s qualification requirements. The new loan has its own rate, term, balance, payment schedule, and closing costs or other fees. The old loan is replaced when the refinance closes; it is not simply adjusted by the current servicer.
A refinance can lower the monthly payment when the new interest rate is lower, when the repayment period is longer, or when both are true. Ask the lender to separate those effects. A payment that falls only because the term is extended may leave you paying for a longer period. Fees also reduce the value of a payment reduction, so compare the amount financed, upfront charges, and total payments over the new term with the existing loan and any modification offer.
Also popular on Amazon
Qualification is a central difference. A lender decides whether to make the new loan under its current requirements. The CFPB identifies market rates, a possible term extension, and whether payments have recently been missed as relevant questions when considering a refinance. Do not assume that an advertised rate or payment is available to you, particularly if your income or expenses have changed or your account is behind. Obtain an actual written offer and ask what conditions must be met before closing.
Which option should you ask about if your mortgage payment is unaffordable?
If you are struggling with the current payment, start by contacting your servicer and asking about all available assistance, including a modification. Refinancing may be worth exploring if you can qualify for a new loan and its actual costs and terms work for you. Neither option is automatically available or better for every borrower.
The CFPB identifies lower market rates or the possibility of lowering payments by extending the loan term as reasons to consider refinancing, while also flagging missed payments as relevant to the decision. If the hardship is expected to continue or you are already behind, ask the servicer what loss-mitigation choices it can review for your loan rather than assuming you can refinance or that a modification will be approved. The CFPB’s foreclosure-avoidance guidance outlines mortgage-assistance options and encourages borrowers to work with their servicer.
Consider these questions as you compare possibilities:
- Is the hardship temporary or likely to last? Tell the servicer what has changed and whether you expect the problem to continue. That context helps it assess the options available to you.
- Are you current or behind? Say so when you contact the servicer. Missed payments can affect the options and terms under consideration.
- Could a new loan actually be affordable? For a refinance, compare the offered rate, term, fees, qualification requirements, and monthly payment—not just an advertised rate or payment estimate.
- Would a lower payment cost more over time? A longer repayment period may reduce the monthly amount while extending how long you pay. A modification may also treat missed payments in a way that increases the balance.
- What does the written offer change? Ask for the actual payment, balance, payoff date, fees, and any trial-plan requirements. A general estimate is not a substitute for the terms offered on your loan.
- Can you sustain the payment after the change? Compare the proposed payment with your realistic household budget, including escrow and other amounts the offer changes. A plan that is unaffordable from the first month is not a durable solution.
- What happens if circumstances change again? Ask whom to contact and what steps apply if income falls, expenses rise, or a trial payment cannot be made. Understanding the process early is safer than waiting for a missed deadline.
How do you compare the real cost of each offer?
Compare the full written terms rather than choosing solely by the smallest monthly payment. A payment reduction can come with a longer repayment period, fees, or a changed balance, so look at both the near-term budget effect and what the change means over the life of the loan.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Also popular on Amazon
- Write down the proposed monthly payment. Confirm what it includes, including escrow and any other amounts changed by the offer. Compare it with your current payment and the amount your household can realistically manage.
- Check the balance and treatment of missed payments. Ask whether unpaid amounts would be added to the balance or handled another way. A lower current payment does not necessarily mean the total amount owed has fallen.
- Compare the repayment period and payoff date. Find out whether the loan term is being extended and when the mortgage would be paid off under the proposed terms.
- For a refinance, list the rate, term, fees, and qualification requirements. Ask how much of the payment reduction comes from a lower rate and how much comes from extending repayment. Include fees in your comparison.
- Read any trial-plan terms carefully. Some modification paths may require a trial plan. Ask what payment is due, when it is due, and what happens after the trial; do not assume a trial estimate is the final permanent offer.
- Compare the offers against your hardship and budget. If an option lowers the payment but leaves it unaffordable, ask about other available assistance rather than accepting a payment you cannot sustain.
- Confirm the source of every number. Use the servicer’s or lender’s written figures for the payment, balance, fees, and payoff date. Keep the documents together so you can compare a modification and a refinance on the same assumptions.
- Consider the short and long view separately. First determine whether the payment solves the immediate affordability problem. Then evaluate the additional months of payments, changed balance, and fees so a short-term reduction does not hide a larger long-term obligation.
The CFPB advises borrowers to understand how a modification affects monthly payments and total amounts owed, and to assess how much a refinance payment reduction depends on a lower rate versus a longer term. See its guidance on modification terms and mortgage-payment options. Your servicer’s actual written offer is what matters for your loan.
What should you do first if you can’t pay your mortgage?
Contact your servicer as soon as you realize you may have trouble making payments. Ask about a mortgage assistance application and all options available for your situation; do not wait for a generic refinance estimate to resolve a payment problem. Early contact gives the servicer time to explain its process and gives you time to gather information.
- Explain the hardship clearly. Describe why the payment is unaffordable, whether the hardship is temporary or expected to continue, and relevant information about income, expenses, and assets.
- Ask what options and paperwork apply to your loan. Request the assistance application and ask how to submit it, what documents are needed, and how to follow up. Requirements vary by loan and circumstance.
- Ask about every available path. Request information on modification, repayment arrangements, forbearance, and any other loss-mitigation option the servicer can review. If you are current, explain that the payment is no longer sustainable; if you are behind, state how many payments are affected and ask how that changes the review.
- Get help understanding the choices. A HUD-approved housing counseling agency can help you understand the servicer’s options, prepare paperwork, and review your broader budget, generally at little or no cost. The CFPB’s mortgage-help resource can help you find guidance. The CFPB also lists the HOPE Hotline at (888) 995-HOPE (4673); verify current contact details when you call.
- Review written terms before deciding. Ask the servicer to explain how the proposal changes the payment, balance, payoff date, fees, and any trial period. Keep copies of the offer and communications.
- Track deadlines and payments. Note application deadlines, trial-plan due dates, requested documents, and the name or reference number for each contact. Follow the instructions in the written notice and promptly report anything you cannot meet.
- Seek legal advice if foreclosure is imminent or you have been served papers. A housing counselor can help with mortgage options, but legal papers call for timely attention from a qualified legal professional.
When you call, ask the servicer to explain whether the person answering is taking an application, what happens next, and how you will receive a decision. Ask where to send documents and how to confirm they were received. Save letters, emails, uploaded files, and payment confirmations. These practical records help you identify conflicting instructions and respond by the required date.
Options other than modification or refinancing may also be available. The CFPB lists repayment plans, forbearance, short sales, and deeds-in-lieu of foreclosure among possibilities a servicer may consider. Forbearance may pause or reduce payments temporarily, but it does not forgive them; repayment, deferral, or modification may be considered depending on the circumstances. Read the CFPB’s guidance on planning for the end of forbearance if that applies to you. Ask specifically how paused amounts will be repaid, deferred, or otherwise handled before the forbearance ends.
Recommended Free Tools
How do temporary hardship options differ from a modification?
Forbearance is generally a temporary pause or reduction in payments, not forgiveness. The payments that are paused or reduced still require a plan. Depending on the circumstances, the servicer may discuss repayment, deferral, or a later modification. A repayment plan can require extra amounts in addition to the regular payment, while a deferral may move amounts to a later point; the actual treatment depends on the servicer’s offer and the loan.
Also popular on Amazon
A short sale or deed-in-lieu of foreclosure can be considered when keeping the home is not workable, but these are different decisions from making an unaffordable payment manageable. Ask the servicer about eligibility, timing, and the written consequences of any alternative. Do not assume that one option is automatically available because it appears on a general list.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.What mortgage-relief warning signs should you avoid?
Be cautious of anyone who charges an upfront fee, guarantees a loan change or foreclosure prevention, asks you to sign over your home’s title, or tells you to stop making mortgage payments. You do not have to hire a company to contact your servicer or get help from a HUD-approved counselor.
Stopping payments on someone else’s advice can harm your credit and limit your options. A missed payment can also affect the loss-mitigation or refinance discussion. Keep communicating with your servicer, and verify any proposed solution directly with it. The CFPB explains why a hired helper’s advice to stop paying is a warning sign. If someone claims to be affiliated with your servicer, use the contact information on your mortgage statement or the servicer’s verified website rather than relying only on an unsolicited message.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problems2Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minute3Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsQuestions to ask the servicer or lender
- What is the proposed monthly payment, and what escrow or other amounts does it include?
- What will the principal balance be after the change, and how are missed payments treated?
- What interest rate applies, and is it fixed or otherwise subject to a future change under the written terms?
- What is the new payoff date and total repayment period?
- Are there fees, charges, or amounts added to the balance?
- Does the modification require a trial plan, and what are the trial dates and success conditions?
- For a refinance, what lender requirements must be met and what costs are due to obtain the new loan?
- What happens if the proposed payment becomes unaffordable again?
- Who can explain the offer, and how can you obtain a complete copy for your records?
What is the practical takeaway?
A modification keeps your current mortgage and changes its terms; a refinance replaces it with a new loan that you must qualify for and that generally has fees. If payments are unaffordable, speak with your servicer promptly, compare written terms—including total costs and the payoff timeline—and consider free or low-cost help from a HUD-approved counselor. The available and affordable choice depends on your loan and circumstances, and no generic estimate can substitute for the actual offer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a mortgage modification add missed payments to my loan balance?
It may: some modification paths add missed payments to the amount owed, while the treatment depends on the offer. Ask the servicer to show the proposed balance and explain how the missed amounts are handled before you agree.
Also popular on Amazon
- It can be a gift option
- Comes with secure packaging
- Helpful in various ways
Can a modification reduce my principal?
The CFPB lists forbearing or reducing principal as possible modification mechanisms, but no particular borrower is guaranteed that treatment. Ask the servicer exactly how principal and any deferred amount would appear in the written offer.
Can I refinance if I have missed mortgage payments?
Recent missed payments are relevant to the refinance decision, and a new lender generally requires you to qualify. Do not assume a refinance is available; ask your servicer about loss-mitigation options and obtain an actual lender decision rather than relying on an advertised rate.
What happens when mortgage forbearance ends?
Forbearance pauses or reduces payments temporarily; it does not erase them. Depending on your circumstances, the servicer may consider repayment, deferral, or modification, so ask about the exit terms before the pause ends.
Can a lower refinance payment still cost more?
Yes. A lower payment may result from extending the repayment term, and refinancing usually includes fees. Compare the new term, balance, fees, payoff date, and total repayment—not only the monthly amount.
The Bottom Line
Bottom line: A modification changes your current mortgage; a refinance replaces it with a new loan and usually requires qualification and fees. Call the servicer early, obtain written terms, compare payment and total cost, and use a HUD-approved counselor for help.
