XTB vs Degiro Compared Who is Better Broker

by

Choosing an online broker can feel like navigating a labyrinth—especially with so many options that promise investment opportunities but differ significantly in their offerings, fee structures, tools, and client experience. For U.S.-based investors, understanding the nuances between platforms like XTB and Degiro is crucial to aligning your investment goals with a broker that fits your trading style and financial aspirations.

Today, I’ll take a comprehensive, in-depth look at XTB and Degiro, evaluating their features, account offerings, costs, platform usability, research tools, regulations, customer support, and overall suitability for different types of investors. Whether you’re a beginner dipping your toes into trading or a seasoned investor seeking more advanced tools, my aim is to help you make an informed decision grounded in clarity and understanding.

Let’s embark on this detailed comparison and discover who might be the better broker for your needs.

1. Overview of XTB and Degiro

1.1. What Is XTB?

XTB, founded in 2002 and headquartered in Poland, is a global online trading platform offering a wide range of financial instruments, including forex, indices, commodities, stocks, ETFs, and cryptocurrencies. Known for its robust proprietary trading platform xStation 5, XTB has built a reputation for user-friendly interfaces and competitive spreads.

Regulation & Reputation

XTB is regulated by notable authorities, including the UK’s FCA, Poland’s KNF, and others, providing a level of trust for traders. Over the years, it has been awarded various industry recognitions, reinforcing its credibility.

1.2. What Is Degiro?

Degiro, established in 2008 in the Netherlands, is primarily a low-cost broker catering to European investors and, increasingly, U.S. clients through its international platform. Its core appeal is its fee transparency and low-cost access to a wide array of global markets, especially for those interested in ETFs, stocks, options, and bonds.

Regulation & Reputation

Degiro is regulated by the Dutch AFM and Dutch Central Bank and holds registrations with other European authorities. Its strong focus on low fees and broad market access has made it popular among active traders and long-term investors alike.

2. Core Offerings and Market Access

2.1. Asset Classes Available

Feature XTB Degiro
Forex & CFDs Yes No (only CFDs when applicable)
Stocks Yes Yes
ETFs Yes Yes
Indices Yes Yes
Commodities Yes Yes
Cryptocurrencies Yes No (limited offerings)
Bonds & Fixed Income Limited Yes indirectly via ETFs

Insight: While both brokers offer access to stocks, ETFs, and indices, XTB provides forex and CFDs, catering to traders seeking leveraged instruments. Conversely, Degiro operates more as a traditional broker focusing on long-term investing with fewer leveraged products.

2.2. Market Accessibility

  • XTB offers access to over 2000 markets globally across forex, commodities, indices, and shares.
  • Degiro provides access to more than 50 global markets, including US, European, and Asian exchanges, with a focus on stocks and ETFs.

Implication for Investors

  • If you’re interested in forex or trading CFDs, XTB is a compelling choice.
  • For investors aiming for diversification with low-cost ETFs and stock trading, Degiro’s broad market access is advantageous.

3. Fee Structures and Costs

Understanding how brokers charge is fundamental to determining overall profitability and trading efficiency.

3.1. Spreads and Commissions

XTB

  • Forex & CFDs: Spreads from 0.1 pip for major pairs, but spreads can vary based on market conditions.
  • Stocks & ETFs: Typically commission-free for stocks listed on certain markets; others may incur small commissions.
  • Cryptocurrencies: Spreads start from 1%.

Degiro

  • Stocks & ETFs: Low flat-fee commissions, often as low as €2-€4 ($2.15-$4.30) per trade for U.S. stocks.
  • ETFs: Many are commission-free if traded via their platform.
  • Other Assets: Bonds, options, and derivatives incur minimal fees.

3.2. Inactivity and Withdrawal Fees

  • XTB: No inactivity fee if trading occurs regularly; withdrawal fees depend on the method.
  • Degiro: No inactivity fee but charges a small fee for most withdrawal methods.

3.3. Additional Costs

  • Data Fees: XTB offers free real-time quotes; Degiro provides free data for U.S. stocks but charges for real-time European market data.
  • Margin & Leverage: XTB offers leverage up to 1:30 for retail clients; Degiro limits margin trading and is more geared toward cash trading.

Summary: Generally, Degiro is favored for its transparent, low-cost commission structure, especially for long-term investors, while XTB’s fee model is more aligned with active trading, particularly in leveraged instruments.

4. Trading Platforms and User Experience

4.1. Platforms Offered

XTB

  • xStation 5 (Proprietary)
    • User-friendly, fast, and intuitive.
    • Incorporates advanced trading tools, charts, and analysis.
    • Includes mobile and web versions.

Degiro

  • Degiro’s Platform
    • Web-based platform is straightforward and ideal for buy-and-hold investors.
    • Does not offer advanced charting tools or custom indicators.
    • No dedicated desktop software; mobile app available with limited features.

Implication: For active traders requiring sophisticated charting and quick execution, XTB’s xStation 5 is more capable. For passive investors who prefer simple order execution, Degiro’s interface suffices.

4.2. Trading Features and Tools

  • Research & Analysis:
    • XTB provides real-time data, news feeds, economic calendars, and charting tools.
    • Degiro offers minimal research tools but provides access to external research sources.
  • Order Types:
    • Both brokers support basic order types such as market and limit orders.
    • XTB offers advanced orders, trailing stops, and stop-loss functionalities.

Overall: If your trading relies heavily on technical analysis and quick order execution, XTB’s platform is more suitable.

5. Regulation and Security of Funds

5.1. Regulatory Oversight

  • XTB
    • Regulated by FCA (UK), KNF (Poland), CySEC (Cyprus), and others.
    • Segregates client funds, ensuring safety.
  • Degiro
    • Regulated by AFM in the Netherlands, with investor protection schemes in place.
    • Segregation of client funds.

5.2. Investor Protection Schemes

  • XTB and Degiro participate in respective investor compensation schemes, providing a safety net up to certain limits.

Takeaway: Both brokers comply with European financial regulations, offering reliable safeguards for U.S. investors operating through their European subsidiaries.

6. Customer Support and Educational Resources

6.1. Customer Support

  • XTB
    • Offers multilingual support via phone, email, and live chat.
    • Support available 24/5.
  • Degiro
    • Support via email, limited phone support.
    • Customer service reviews suggest responsiveness but occasionally slower.

6.2. Educational Tools and Resources

  • XTB
    • Rich educational content, webinars, tutorials, and market analysis.
    • Designed for traders of all levels.
  • Degiro
    • Less emphasis on education; primarily a trading platform with minimal tutorials.

Summary: If ongoing education and personalized support are priorities, XTB offers more comprehensive resources.

7. Ease of Funding and Account Opening

7.1. Account Opening Process

  • XTB
    • Simple online registration.
    • Verification typically completed within 1-2 days.
  • Degiro
    • Straightforward onboarding process.
    • Verification and approval often within a few days.

7.2. Funding Options

  • XTB
    • Bank transfer, credit/debit cards.
  • Degiro
    • Bank transfer, SEPA transfers.

Note: U.S. clients need to check whether cross-border funding is supported or if they can open accounts directly or via European subsidiaries.

8. Suitability for U.S. Investors

8.1. Accessibility and Regulations

  • XTB
    • US clients can access XTB via its offshore entity (if permitted), but direct access may be limited.
  • Degiro
    • Limited direct offerings to U.S. investors; better suited for European investors.

Insight: Both brokers are predominantly European-focused. U.S. investors should verify whether they can open accounts and the legal considerations involved.

8.2. Alternatives and Regional Considerations

  • For American-based investors, brokers specifically regulated in the U.S., such as Charles Schwab, TD Ameritrade, or Interactive Brokers, are often more suitable.

9. Pros and Cons Summary

XTB

Pros

  • Advanced proprietary platform (xStation 5)
  • Wide array of assets including forex and CFDs
  • Strong regulation and safety
  • Extensive research and educational resources
  • User-friendly interface

Cons

  • Higher spreads on forex and CFDs compared to pure stock brokers
  • Not ideal for long-term buy-and-hold stock investors (due to CFD offerings)
  • Limited access for U.S. clients

Degiro

Pros

  • Extremely low fees for ETFs and stocks
  • Broad international market access
  • Suitable for long-term investors and active traders
  • Transparent pricing model

Cons

  • Limited research tools and educational content
  • No forex or CFD trading
  • Less sophisticated trading platform
  • Limited features for active traders / advanced orders

10. Final Verdict: Who Is the Better Broker?

The answer hinges entirely on your individual trading style, investment goals, and market interests.

  • Choose XTB if…
    • You are an active trader or trader interested in forex, CFDs, and leverage.
    • You value a powerful trading platform with technical analysis tools.
    • You prefer strong regulation and educational support.
  • Choose Degiro if…
    • You are a long-term investor seeking low-cost access to global equities and ETFs.
    • You prefer simplicity and transparency in costs.
    • You are less interested in leveraged trading or advanced trading tools.

For U.S.-based investors, neither may be the optimal first choice unless they qualify to open accounts, as local U.S. brokers tend to offer more tailored U.S.-regulation safety nets and services.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Is it safe to trade with XTB and Degiro?

Yes. Both brokers are regulated by reputable European authorities. They adhere to strict segregation of client funds and investor protection schemes, ensuring a high level of security.

2. Which broker has lower fees?

Degiro generally offers lower commissions and fees, especially for stock and ETF trades, making it highly cost-efficient for passive investing. XTB’s fees can be higher due to spreads and additional costs associated with CFD trading.

3. Can U.S. investors open accounts with XTB or Degiro?

Both brokers primarily serve European and international clients. U.S. residents should verify each broker’s specific terms and consider U.S.-regulated alternatives for seamless regulatory compliance.

4. Which platform is easier to use for beginners?

Degiro’s platform is straightforward, ideal for beginners, though it offers limited research tools. XTB’s xStation 5 provides advanced features but may have a steeper learning curve for newcomers.

5. Do these brokers support mobile trading?

Yes. Both brokers offer mobile apps compatible with iOS and Android devices, providing trading on the go.

6. What kind of customer support can I expect?

XTB is known for responsive, multilingual support, including live chat. Degiro’s support is adequate but may respond more slowly, especially via email.

7. Are there demo accounts available?

Yes, both brokers offer demo accounts allowing users to practice trading without risking real money, ideal for testing platforms and strategies.

8. What are the account minimums?

Generally, both brokers do not enforce strict minimum deposits, but check the specific requirements before opening an account.

9. Which broker offers better research and educational tools?

XTB provides a comprehensive set of educational materials, webinars, and market analyses, whereas Degiro offers minimal educational content, making XTB better suited for traders seeking ongoing learning.

Final Thoughts

Investing success hinges not just on your knowledge but also on choosing a broker that aligns with your trading style, costs, and strategic goals. While XTB excels in active trading environments with advanced tools and broad asset classes, Degiro shines as a low-cost, straightforward platform for long-term investors.

In the complex landscape of online brokerage, understanding these differences is vital. The right choice isn’t necessarily the “best” broker objectively but the one that fits your unique investment journey.

Remember, always perform your due diligence, consider your risk tolerance, and ensure your chosen broker complies with relevant regulations to safeguard your financial future.

Leave a Comment