XM vs Forex.com Compared Who is Better Broker

by

XM vs Forex.com Compared: Who is the Better Broker?

Navigating the complex landscape of online forex brokers can feel overwhelming, especially when trying to find a trustworthy platform that aligns with your trading goals. Two names that often come up in the conversation are XM and Forex.com—both giants in the industry, boasting built-in credibility and a wide array of offerings. As an experienced finance content writer who’s been in this space for years, I understand the importance of dissecting these brokers thoroughly, from their platforms to their customer service, to help traders make informed decisions.

In this comprehensive guide, I’ll walk you through every critical aspect of XM and Forex.com, comparing their strengths and weaknesses, features, fee structures, regulatory standing, educational resources, trading tools, and more. This isn’t just a dry review; it’s a humanized, practical breakdown crafted to give traders like you clarity, confidence, and insight.

Let’s begin this detailed comparison by examining each broker’s background, reputation, and regulatory status.

1. Broker Background and Regulation

1.1. XM: Overview and Regulatory Status

XM is a well-established online broker founded in 2009, operating under Trading Point Holdings Ltd. which holds licenses from several prominent regulators, including:

  • Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) — Australia
  • Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) — European Union
  • Finsa Europe Ltd. also holds registration with the Financial Services Authority (FSA) in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines.

Strengths:

  • Broad regulatory coverage reassures traders of operating transparency.
  • CySEC regulation allows for adherence to the EU’s strong investor protection rules.
  • ASIC licensing in Australia is highly respected, adding credibility.

Weaknesses:

  • Some of XM’s entities are regulated outside the US, which means that US traders typically cannot open accounts directly with XM due to regulatory restrictions.

1.2. Forex.com: Overview and Regulatory Status

Forex.com, part of GAIN Capital Holdings, has a history dating back over two decades. Regulatory approval is particularly extensive in the US, which is a critical factor for American traders:

  • National Futures Association (NFA)
  • Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)
  • Registered with the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the UK
  • Regulated by Investors’ Protection Fund (IPF) in the UK

Strengths:

  • U.S. regulation by NFA and CFTC ensures adherence to strict standards, making Forex.com a reliable choice for American traders.
  • Clear compliance protocols and transparency in operations.
  • Deep liquidity and robust risk management due to regulation.

Weaknesses:

  • Limited leverage options for U.S clients (regulated firms are often limited in their leverage offerings to protect retail traders).
  • Non-U.S traders may have fewer options to open accounts directly depending on jurisdiction restrictions.

1.3. Summary

Both brokers hold solid regulatory licenses in major jurisdictions. However, Forex.com is heavily regulated in the U.S., making it a more suitable choice for American traders prioritizing regulatory oversight and compliance. Conversely, XM’s international licenses serve traders outside the U.S. well but may have limitations for U.S. residents.

2. Trading Platforms and Technology

2.1. XM: Platforms Offered

XM provides:

  • MetaTrader 4 (MT4)
  • MetaTrader 5 (MT5)

Features:

  • Both platforms are widely recognized for their stability, algorithmic trading capabilities, and customizability.
  • The platforms support automated trading via Expert Advisors (EAs).
  • Web-based versions and mobile apps are available for seamless trading on the go.

User Experience:

  • Intuitive interfaces suited for beginners yet offering advanced tools for experienced traders.
  • Multiple charting tools, technical indicators, and analytical features.

2.2. Forex.com: Platforms Offered

Forex.com offers:

  • Trading via MetaTrader 4 (MT4) (available in certain jurisdictions)
  • Forex.com’s proprietary platform — sophisticated and highly user-friendly
  • TradingView integration (limited but expanding)
  • Mobile App with comprehensive features
  • Web-based platform accessible via browsers

Features:

  • Proprietary platform designed specifically for ease of use for retail traders.
  • Advanced charting tools, customizable workspace, and real-time data.
  • Access to proprietary tools like live news, research, and alerts.

2.3. Comparison

Feature XM Forex.com
Platforms Supported MT4, MT5 Proprietary + MT4 (select markets)
User Interface Simple, beginner-friendly Modern and intuitive
Charting Tools Advanced Advanced
Mobile Trading Yes Yes
Automated Trading EAs Supported Expert Advisors + Proprietary Manual Trading

Summary: Both brokers provide robust platform options with competitive features. XM’s use of MT4 and MT5 makes it flexible for automated traders, while Forex.com’s tailored platform offers a smooth experience optimized for retail traders.

3. Product Offerings and Market Coverage

3.1. Currency Pairs

XM:

  • Offers over 55 currency pairs
  • Major, minor, and exotic pairs included

Forex.com:

  • Offers about 80 currency pairs
  • Focus on major and minor pairs, with some exotics

3.2. Other Instruments

XM:

  • CFDs on indices, commodities, cryptocurrencies, metals, energies, and stocks

Forex.com:

  • Ranges beyond forex to include CFDs on indices, commodities, cryptocurrencies, futures, and options

3.3. Market Hours and Liquidity

Both brokers offer 24-hour trading during major global sessions, with tight spreads, especially around high liquidity hours. Forex.com’s longstanding reputation as a U.S.-regulated broker ensures deep liquidity, with robust execution speeds.

4. Account Types and Pricing

4.1. XM Account Types

  • Micro Account
  • Standard Account
  • XM Ultra Low Account

Features:

  • Spreads from 0.0 pips on some accounts
  • No commission on Standard and Micro accounts; commission applies on Ultra Low accounts
  • Leverage up to 1:888 (varies by jurisdiction)

4.2. Forex.com Account Types

  • Standard Account (with spreads around 1.2 pips)
  • Commission Account (reduced spreads with a commission per trade)
  • Active Trader Program (tiered discounts for high-volume traders)

Features:

  • Competitive spreads
  • No minimum deposit
  • Leverage up to 1:50 for U.S. traders (regulated constraints)

4.3. Fee Structures

While both brokers offer competitive spreads, the fee structure varies:

  • XM: No commission on most accounts, spreads are the primary cost.
  • Forex.com: Offers both spread-only accounts and commission-inclusive accounts, giving traders flexibility.

Summary: XM tends to attract traders who prefer fixed or variable spreads without commissions, while Forex.com appeals to traders seeking potentially lower costs with commission-based trading.

5. Leverage and Margin

5.1. XM Leverage Policy

  • Leverage up to 1:888 (regulated jurisdictions support high leverage; with stricter limits in some regions)
  • Leverage is offered based on account type and jurisdiction

5.2. Forex.com Leverage Policy

  • Leverage is up to 1:50 in line with U.S. regulations
  • Reduced leverage to promote safer trading practices

5.3. Implications for Traders

Higher leverage carries increased risk, especially for inexperienced traders. XM’s higher leverage is suitable only for traders well-versed in risk management. Forex.com’s conservative leverage aligns with U.S. regulatory standards, promoting safer trading.

6. Spreads, Commissions, and Costs

6.1. XM’s Cost Transparency

  • Spreads starting from 0.0 pips on some accounts
  • No commissions on most accounts, benefitting scalpers and day traders
  • Overnight swap rates vary with currency pairs and account types

6.2. Forex.com’s Cost Structure

  • Spreads from around 1.2 pips on standard accounts
  • Commissions in some account types, especially the Pro account
  • Additional fees may apply for withdrawals or inactivity

6.3. Overall Cost Effectiveness

In the long run, traders must consider spread costs, commissions, swap rates, and fees for deposits/withdrawals. Both brokers are competitive, but the best choice depends on trading style—frequent traders might prefer XM’s tight spreads, while professional traders may favor Forex.com’s tiered accounts with lower spreads and commissions.

7. Customer Support and Education

7.1. XM Customer Support

  • 24/5 multilingual support via live chat, email, and phone
  • Extensive educational resources, including webinars, tutorials, and market analysis
  • Trader training programs and demo accounts

7.2. Forex.com Customer Support

  • 24/5 support through live chat, email, and phone
  • Deep market insights, research articles, webinars
  • Strong educational repository and dedicated client portal

7.3. Educational Resources

XM:

  • Comprehensive tutorials geared toward beginners
  • Regular webinars with expert traders
  • Demo accounts for practice

Forex.com:

  • Active webinar series
  • Market analysis tools
  • Interactive tutorials and courses

Summary: Both brokers excel in customer support and education, targeting traders at various levels. Forex.com’s educational content is more extensive and research-focused, while XM offers a solid foundation for new traders.

8. Bonuses, Promotions, and Loyalty Programs

8.1. XM Promotions

  • Welcome bonuses and deposit bonuses (availability varies by country due to regulatory restrictions)
  • Loyalty programs rewarding regular traders
  • No deposit bonuses are often limited or unavailable in regulated jurisdictions

8.2. Forex.com Promotions

  • Occasionally offers promotional spreads and discounts
  • No major bonuses due to stringent U.S. regulatory rules
  • Emphasizes transparent pricing instead

Note: Promotions and bonuses are often subject to regional restrictions; US traders generally cannot access bonuses due to regulatory policies.

9. Deposit and Withdrawal Methods

9.1. XM

  • Supports bank wire transfers, credit/debit cards, e-wallets (Skrill, Neteller)
  • Withdrawals typically processed within 24 hours
  • No deposit/withdrawal fees in most cases

9.2. Forex.com

  • Bank transfers, debit/credit cards, PayPal, and ACH transfers
  • Withdrawals processed swiftly
  • Currency conversions may apply

10. Security and Trustworthiness

Both brokers maintain high security standards, including data encryption, segregated client funds, and regular audit processes. Forex.com, being a U.S.-regulated broker, adheres to the strictest compliance and financial standards. XM’s multiple international licenses further validate its credibility.

11. Final Verdict: Who Is the Better Broker?

Making a definitive choice between XM and Forex.com depends heavily on your individual trading profile, jurisdiction, regulatory preferences, and trading objectives.

Choose XM if:

  • You are outside the U.S. or in regions where XM operates under regulatory licenses.
  • You prefer higher leverage (be cautious and use proper risk management).
  • You seek a wide array of products beyond forex.
  • You are interested in trading with tight spreads and no commissions.

Choose Forex.com if:

  • You are based in the United States or require strict regulatory oversight.
  • You prioritize regulatory compliance, transparency, and security.
  • You prefer a proprietary platform with integrated research tools.
  • You are a professional or institutional trader seeking sophisticated trading features.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Is it safe to trade with XM or Forex.com?

Both brokers are regulated in major jurisdictions, which significantly reduces counterparty risk. Forex.com, being heavily regulated in the U.S., offers a particularly high level of oversight. For international traders, XM’s licenses in Europe and Australia offer a good level of safety.

2. Can U.S. traders open accounts with XM?

Typically, no. Due to U.S. regulations, XM does not accept U.S. residents directly. US traders should opt for brokers like Forex.com that are regulated domestically.

3. Which broker offers better trading conditions?

XM often provides narrower spreads and higher leverage options, which can be advantageous for short-term traders. However, the U.S. regulations limit leverage in Forex.com, promoting safer trading.

4. Are there any bonuses or promotions?

Most bonuses are region-specific. US traders generally cannot access deposit bonuses with Forex.com due to regulatory restrictions, and XM’s bonuses are limited outside of certain jurisdictions.

5. Which broker is better for beginners?

Both brokers offer educational resources, demo accounts, and user-friendly platforms. XM has a slight edge with its extensive tutorials and webinars tailored for beginners.

6. How do the withdrawal and deposit processes compare?

Both brokers support popular methods such as bank transfers and e-wallets, with timely processing and minimal fees if any.

7. What are the main disadvantages of each broker?

  • XM: Limited regulation in the U.S. and certain regions, higher leverage can pose risk.
  • Forex.com: Lower leverage limits for U.S. traders, potentially higher spreads on some accounts.

Conclusion

There is no one-size-fits-all answer to “who is the better broker,” as it largely depends on your location, trading preferences, risk appetite, and regulatory priorities. Both XM and Forex.com are reputable, well-established brokers offering a wide range of trading tools, competitive pricing, and strong security measures.

If you are a trader outside the U.S. who values high leverage, a broad product portfolio, and tight spreads, XM might be the preferable choice. Conversely, if you are based in the U.S. or prioritize regulation and regulatory protections, Forex.com is likely the safer route with a track record of compliance and stability.

In the end, your ideal broker aligns with your trading style, risk management approach, and regulatory comfort zone. Take the time to evaluate your priorities carefully, utilize demo accounts for testing, and adopt a cautious approach with leverage and risk—trading is a marathon, not a sprint.

Happy trading, and remember: knowledge and careful planning are your best tools in navigating the forex markets effectively.

Leave a Comment