Tickmill vs IC Markets Compared Who is Better Broker

by

Tickmill vs IC Markets: Who is the Better Broker?

Choosing the right trading broker is a crucial step in your journey toward successful trading and investing. Among the myriad of brokers available worldwide, Tickmill and IC Markets stand out as two prominent players, particularly in the Forex and CFD trading spheres. Both brokers have carved out a reputation for reliability, competitive pricing, and efficient trading platforms, but how do they truly compare? Which one suits your trading style and goals better?

In this comprehensive comparison, we will delve deep into the various facets of Tickmill and IC Markets – from regulation and trading conditions to platform offerings, fees, customer support, and more. Whether you’re a seasoned trader or just starting, understanding the nuances of these brokers can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your financial aspirations.

Let’s begin by getting to know each broker a little better before diving into the details.

An Overview of Tickmill and IC Markets

Who is Tickmill?

Tickmill was founded in 2014 and has quickly gained traction among retail traders due to its transparent fee structure, strong regulatory framework, and user-friendly platforms. Based in the UK and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), Tickmill has established itself as a trustworthy broker with a focus on Forex trading, CFDs on indices, commodities, precious metals, and cryptocurrencies.

Key Highlights of Tickmill:

  • Regulated by FCA (UK), FSA (Seychelles), and FSCA (South Africa).
  • Offers a range of account types including Classic, Pro, and VIP.
  • Provides competitive spreads and low commissions.
  • Offers MetaTrader 4 (MT4), MetaTrader 5 (MT5), and a proprietary platform.
  • Known for excellent customer service and educational resources.

Who is IC Markets?

IC Markets was established in 2007, making it one of the longer-standing brokers in the industry. Based in Australia and regulated by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), IC Markets has earned praise for its ultra-low spreads, execution speed, and robust platform options.

Key Highlights of IC Markets:

  • Regulated by ASIC, CySEC, and FSA (Seychelles).
  • Offers ECN trading environment with raw spreads.
  • Provides MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, and a proprietary platform.
  • Focuses on transparency, speed, and low-cost trading.
  • Excellent for high-frequency traders and scalpers due to its strict execution standards.

Having laid out the basic profiles, let’s now compare these brokers across essential trading facets, starting with regulation and safety.

Regulation and Safety of Funds

Why Regulation Matters

When selecting a broker, regulation is perhaps the most critical factor. It ensures that the broker complies with certain standards of transparency, security, and fair trading practices. Regulation also significantly decreases the risk of broker insolvency or malpractices that could jeopardize your funds.

Tickmill’s Regulatory Status

Tickmill operates under multiple regulatory umbrellas, primarily:

  • Financial Conduct Authority (FCA, UK): This is one of the most respected financial regulators globally, imposing strict capital requirements and conduct standards.
  • FSA (Seychelles): A less-stringent regulator with fewer client fund protection measures.
  • FSCA (South Africa): Regulates Tickmill South Africa, ensuring regional compliance.

Implication for Traders:
The FCA regulation provides a high level of investor protection, segregation of client funds, and adherence to strict operational standards. However, the Seychelles regulation offers less investor protection but still provides some safeguards.

IC Markets’ Regulatory Environment

IC Markets is regulated by:

  • ASIC (Australia): Renowned for strict regulations, including stringent capital requirements and regular audits.
  • CySEC (Cyprus): European regulation that offers similar safeguards within the EU.
  • FSA (Seychelles): As with Tickmill, Seychelles regulation is more lenient and mainly for regional operations.

Implication for Traders:
ASIC regulation makes IC Markets one of the safest brokers, especially for traders in the U.S. (via global account offerings). CySEC regulation also ensures adherence to European standards, including segregation of client funds and mandatory reporting.

Final Thoughts on Regulation

Both brokers are regulated, but Tickmill’s FCA approval slightly enhances its credibility and safety profile, especially for traders concerned about regulatory oversight. IC Markets, with its ASIC regulation, is also exceptionally safe, particularly for high-volume or professional traders.

When considering regulations, you should always verify whether the broker offers segregated client accounts, negative balance protection, and transparent operational policies—features common to both brokers.

Trading Conditions and Platform Offerings

Spreads, Commissions, and Fees

One of the most critical aspects for traders is the cost of trading, primarily reflected in spreads and commissions.

Tickmill’s Trading Conditions

  • Spreads: Starting from 0.0 pips on the Pro accounts and slightly wider on Classic accounts.
  • Commissions: $2 per lot on Pro accounts; Classic accounts are commission-free but with slightly wider spreads.
  • Execution: ECN/STP execution with minimal slippage and fast order fills.
  • Leverage: Up to 1:500 depending on the account type and regulation.

IC Markets’ Trading Conditions

  • Spreads: From 0.0 pips on ECN accounts; typical spreads are around 0.1 to 0.3 pips.
  • Commissions: $3.50 per lot round-turn on raw spread accounts.
  • Execution: ECN environment with some of the fastest execution speeds in the industry.
  • Leverage: Up to 1:500, regulated by ASIC and CySEC.

Comparison Summary:

Feature Tickmill IC Markets
Typical Spreads From 0.0 pips (Pro) From 0.0 pips (ECN)
Commissions $2 per lot $3.50 per lot (raw spreads)
Execution Speed Very fast, ECN/STP Very fast, ECN/STP
Default Leverage Up to 1:500 Up to 1:500

Insight:
While both brokers boast tight spreads and low trading fees, IC Markets’ raw spreads with additional commissions can sometimes work out cheaper for ultra-active traders, especially those focusing on scalping or high-frequency trading.

Trading Platforms Offered

Tickmill Platforms

  • MetaTrader 4 (MT4): Industry-standard platform known for stability, extensive tools, Expert Advisors (EAs).
  • MetaTrader 5 (MT5): Modern upgrade offering more assets, richer charting, and order types.
  • Tickmill Web Trader: Simple web-based platform for quick access.
  • Mobile Apps: Fully functional on iOS and Android.

IC Markets Platforms

  • MetaTrader 4 & MetaTrader 5: Similar robust offerings, favored by traders worldwide.
  • cTrader: Preferred by some for its advanced order management and algorithmic trading tools.
  • WebTrader & Mobile Apps: Comprehensive and user-friendly.

Key Takeaway:
Both brokers provide a broad range of platform options, with MetaTrader being common and trusted among traders. IC Markets’ cTrader is a noteworthy advantage for traders preferring a more intuitive and advanced order execution environment.

Asset Offerings

Understanding the range of assets available is paramount.

Tickmill Asset Spectrum

  • Forex: Over 80 currency pairs.
  • Indices: Major global indices like US30, UK100, etc.
  • Commodities: Gold, silver, oil, and other energy products.
  • Cryptocurrencies: Bitcoin, Ethereum, and more.
  • Precious Metals: Gold, silver.

IC Markets Asset Spectrum

  • Forex: Over 60 currency pairs.
  • Indices: Global indices including US, Europe, Asia.
  • Commodities: Gold, oil, natural gas.
  • Cryptocurrencies: BTC, ETH, LTC, XRP.
  • Shares and ETFs: Available through CFD trading.

Comparison:
Both brokers offer comparable asset classes, with IC Markets slightly more focused on shares and ETFs via CFDs, while Tickmill emphasizes Forex and Commodities.

Customer Support and User Experience

Support Quality

Tickmill

  • Multiple support channels: live chat, email, phone.
  • Knowledge base and educational resources.
  • Support available in several languages.
  • Fast response times reported by users.

IC Markets

  • 24/5 support via live chat, email, phone.
  • Extensive FAQ and trading guides.
  • Multilingual support.
  • Recognized for promptness and professionalism.

User Interface and Ease of Use

Both brokers offer intuitive platforms—MetaTrader 4 and 5 are familiar to most traders. IC Markets’ cTrader and Tickmill’s proprietary web trader provide additional options for users seeking different interfaces.

Educational Resources

  • Tickmill offers webinars, tutorials, market analysis, and trading guides.
  • IC Markets also provides comprehensive educational content, including videos and blogs.

Summary:
Both brokers excel in customer experience with responsive support and rich educational offerings. Your choice may hinge on platform preference.

Deposit and Withdrawal Options

Tickmill

  • Accepted Methods: Bank wire, credit/debit cards, e-wallets (Skrill, Neteller).
  • Processing Time: Instant to 1-2 business days depending on method.
  • Minimum Deposit: Varies by account type, typically $250.

IC Markets

  • Accepted Methods: Bank transfer, credit/debit cards, e-wallets.
  • Processing Time: Instant to 24 hours.
  • Minimum Deposit: Usually $200.

Both brokers offer similar, flexible deposit options with low minimums, suitable for U.S. traders.

Account Types and Suitability

Tickmill Accounts

  • Classic Account: No commission, wider spreads.
  • Pro Account: Lower spreads, $2 commission.
  • VIP Account: For high-volume traders, tailored conditions.

IC Markets Accounts

  • Standard Account: No commissions, wider spreads.
  • Raw Spread Account: Low spreads with commissions.
  • CTrader Account: Designed for cTrader platform users.

Which Trader Fits Which?

  • Beginners: Tickmill Classic or IC Markets Standard.
  • Active Traders/Scalpers: Tickmill Pro or IC Markets Raw Spread.
  • High-Volume Traders: Tickmill VIP or IC Markets VIP.

Fees, Limits, and Transparency

Both brokers maintain transparency on fees and limits. It’s essential to review the specific terms, especially for overnight swaps, commissions, and restrictions on trading hours or account leverage.

Final Verdict: Who is the Better Broker?

The answer depends heavily on your trading style, regulatory preferences, and platform choices. Both brokers are highly reputable, regulated, and cost-effective; however, nuances may sway your decision.

When to Choose Tickmill

  • You prioritize UK regulation and high regulatory standards.
  • You prefer a straightforward trading environment.
  • You desire a diverse range of account types and educational resources.
  • You trade predominantly Forex or CFDs but prefer a slightly simpler fee structure.

When to Choose IC Markets

  • You are a high-frequency or scalping trader, needing ultra-fast execution.
  • You prefer raw spreads and a broader asset selection.
  • You value multiple platform options, especially cTrader.
  • You seek a broker regulated by ASIC with solid reputation for speed.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Are Tickmill and IC Markets suitable for U.S. traders?

Both brokers primarily serve international clients outside the U.S. due to regulatory restrictions. U.S. traders should seek brokers regulated by FINRA or the CFTC. However, some U.S.-based traders access their services via offshore accounts, but this involves higher risk.

2. Which broker offers better leverage?

Both offer leverage up to 1:500, but actual leverage depends on your jurisdiction and account type. Always check current limits as regulatory changes can affect leverage.

3. Do these brokers offer demo accounts?

Yes, both offer free demo accounts with virtual funds for practicing trading strategies.

4. What is the typical withdrawal processing time?

Generally, withdrawals are processed within 1-3 business days, but it may vary by method and broker.

5. Are there any deposit fees?

Both brokers usually do not charge deposit fees, but the payment providers may impose charges.

6. Which broker has better customer support?

Both are highly rated; your experience may vary based on location and support channels preferred.

7. Can I use Expert Advisors (EAs) with these brokers?

Yes, both support EAs through MetaTrader platforms.

8. Is negative balance protection available?

Yes, especially for regulated entities like Tickmill FCA and IC Markets ASIC; it helps prevent losing more than your account balance.

Conclusion

Deciding between Tickmill and IC Markets ultimately hinges on your specific trading requirements and risk profile. Both brokers offer compelling features, competitive costs, and robust regulation, making them excellent choices for traders seeking reliability and efficiency.

If your priority is stringent regulation combined with simple trading conditions, Tickmill might be your choice. Conversely, if you are a trader seeking ultra-low spreads, a diverse platform ecosystem, and cutting-edge trading technology, IC Markets could serve you better.

Remember, no matter which broker you choose, always ensure it aligns with your trading style, risk appetite, and long-term goals. Conduct due diligence, leverage demo accounts to familiarize yourself with the platforms, and develop solid trading strategies to make the most of your trading journey.

Happy trading!

Leave a Comment