Oanda vs XM Compared Who is Better Broker

by

Oanda vs XM Compared: Who is the Better Broker?

When it comes to trading forex and CFDs, choosing the right broker can make or break your trading journey. With hundreds of platforms available, the decision becomes a daunting task, especially for traders in the United States who seek reliability, transparency, and outstanding trading conditions. Two names that continuously surface in inquiries are Oanda and XM. Both have established themselves as reputable brokers with global footprints, but which one truly stands out for U.S. traders?

In this comprehensive review, we’ll peel back the layers of both brokers, analyzing their features, account types, trading platforms, costs, regulation, and customer support. Whether you’re a beginner dipping your toes into forex or an experienced trader looking for the best execution and conditions, this comparison aims to give you an authoritative, empathetic view of who might be the better fit for your trading aspirations.

Overview of Oanda and XM

Who is Oanda?

Founded in 1996, Oanda has long been a trailblazer in the online forex industry. Originating in the United States, the company was one of the earliest brokers to mainstream forex trading, emphasizing transparency, regulation, and educational content. It operates under multiple licenses globally but primarily adheres to strong U.S. regulatory standards, making it highly appealing to traders based in the States.

Who is XM?

XM was established in 2009 and has rapidly grown to become one of the most popular brokers worldwide, especially in Europe and Asia. Known for offering a broad array of assets and a customer-friendly approach, XM has gained a reputation for its extensive educational resources, generous bonuses, and flexible account options. Although it is not based in the U.S., XM caters to U.S. traders via Global accounts and offers a variety of trading instruments.

Licensing and Regulation

Oanda’s Regulatory Environment

One of the most significant advantages of Oanda is its high regulatory standards. It is licensed and regulated by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), and other regulators worldwide such as the UK’s FCA, Canada’s IIROC, and Australia’s ASIC. This multi-jurisdictional oversight ensures that Oanda adheres to strict compliance standards, prioritizing client fund safety and transparency.

XM’s Regulatory Environment

XM is regulated by entities such as the Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC), the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), and the International Financial Services Commission (IFSC) in Belize. While it holds multiple licenses, it is not regulated in the U.S., which may raise concerns for traders who prioritize stringent American regulatory oversight. Nonetheless, XM maintains stringent policies to comply with global standards, but some traders may prefer a broker with direct U.S. licensing.

What Does Regulation Mean for Traders?

Regulation ensures that brokers follow strict standards regarding client fund segregation, transparency, and fair trading practices. For U.S. traders, adherence to U.S. laws and regulations is particularly critical, making Oanda inherently more appealing due to its domestic regulation.

Account Types and Trading Conditions

Oanda’s Account Offerings

Oanda primarily offers a single, straightforward account type designed for flexibility:

  • Standard Trade Account: No minimum deposit restrictions, competitive spreads starting from around 1.0 pip, and transparent pricing. It features no commissions on spot forex trading, with costs embedded in the spreads.

Key Features:

  • Zero deposit fee
  • No minimum deposit requirement
  • Proprietary platform and integrations with MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and TradingView
  • Margin requirements typically at 50:1, aligning with U.S. regulations

XM’s Account Offerings

XM provides a variety of account options to cater to different trading preferences:

  • Micro Account: Suitable for beginners or small traders, with micro lots and tight spreads.
  • Standard Account: Fewer restrictions, larger lot sizes, spreads as low as 1 pip.
  • XM Zero Account: Designed for traders seeking ultra-low spreads starting from 0 pips but with a small commission fee.

Features common across accounts:

  • Flexible deposit options
  • Multiple platforms (MT4, MT5, WebTrader)
  • No requote policy
  • Leverage up to 1:50 for U.S. clients (regulated standards)

Comparing Trading Conditions

Feature Oanda XM
Account Types Single (with variations) Multiple (Micro, Standard, Zero)
Spreads From 1.0 pip; variable From 0.6 pip (XM Zero)
Commission None on standard accounts $3 per lot (XM Zero)
Leverage Up to 50:1 (U.S.) Up to 50:1 (U.S. clients)
Minimum Deposit No minimum $5 – $50 depending on account
Platforms Proprietary, MT4, TradingView MT4, MT5, WebTrader

The Bottom Line on Account Types

For U.S. traders, Oanda’s single, straightforward account aligns with regulatory standards and simplicity. On the other hand, XM offers a broader range of accounts, which can appeal to traders seeking specific trading conditions—particularly low spreads with commissions or very small trading lots.

Trading Platforms and Technological Offerings

Oanda’s Platforms

Oanda offers proprietary and third-party platforms to suit different trading styles:

  • Oanda Desktop Platform: Intuitive, user-friendly interface suitable for beginners.
  • MetaTrader 4 (MT4): A widely used platform with extensive customization options.
  • TradingView: Provides advanced charting and social trading features directly from the broker.
  • Mobile Apps: Robust trading apps compatible with iOS and Android.

Notable Advantages:

  • High reliability and fast execution
  • Customizable charting tools
  • Excellent social and copy trading options via TradingView integration

XM’s Platforms

XM is compatible with:

  • MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and MetaTrader 5 (MT5)—the industry standards offering advanced charting, automated trading, and algorithmic strategies.
  • WebTrader: No-download platform accessible via web browsers.
  • Mobile Apps: Full-featured mobile trading apps supporting MT4/MT5.

Features and Strengths:

  • Seamless MT4/MT5 experience
  • Automated trading through Expert Advisors
  • Multi-asset trading on a single platform (forex, CFDs, cryptocurrencies)

Platform Comparison Summary

Feature Oanda XM
Proprietary platform Yes No (uses MT4/MT5)
Compatibility MT4, TradingView, Mobile MT4, MT5, WebTrader, Mobile
Customization Moderate Extensive via MT4/MT5
Automated Trading Supported through MT4 Fully supported

Insights: If seamless use of popular platforms like MT4 and MT5 is crucial, XM’s extensive platform suite might be more appealing. Oanda’s integration with TradingView introduces a different experience—more social and visually driven, suitable for traders who leverage charting and social trading.

Spreads, Commissions, and Cost of Trading

Oanda’s Cost Structure

Oanda is renowned for its transparent pricing. It operates primarily with a spreads-only model:

  • Spreads start at approximately 1.0 pip for major currency pairs during active market hours.
  • No commission fees on standard accounts.
  • Overnight financing (swap rates) apply based on swaps for holding positions overnight.

XM’s Cost Structure

XM provides two primary pricing models:

  • No commission accounts with spreads starting from 1 pip to 2 pips.
  • XM Zero accounts with spreads as low as 0.6 pip but incurring $3 per lot traded as a commission.

Comparing the Total Cost of Trading

The cost of trading isn’t solely about spreads; swaps, commissions, and rollover fees also play roles. For U.S. traders, the tight regulation limits leverage and aggressive trading policies, indirectly impacting costs.

  • Oanda’s spreads are competitive and transparent, with no hidden fees.
  • XM, especially with the Zero account, can offer lower spreads but adds commission fees; the overall costs depend on trading frequency and position sizes.

Practical Takeaways

For traders prioritizing transparency and simplicity, Oanda’s spreads and fee structure stand out. However, high-frequency traders seeking ultra-tight spreads might prefer XM Zero despite paying commissions.

Leverage and Risk Management

Leverage in the U.S.

Due to regulations by the CFTC and NFA, U.S.-based traders are limited to a maximum leverage of 50:1 for forex trading, or lower, depending on the asset class. Both Oanda and XM adhere to these limits for U.S. clients, ensuring compliance and protection.

Impact of Leverage

Leverage amplifies both profits and losses. While higher leverage can increase potential returns, it also magnifies risk. Both brokers provide risk management tools such as stop-loss orders and negative balance protection to help traders manage risk effectively.

Risk Management Features

  • Oanda offers guaranteed stop-loss orders, which ensure a position closes at specified prices regardless of market gaps.
  • XM provides various order types, including trailing stops, to enhance risk control.

Customer Support and Educational Resources

Oanda

Oanda’s customer support is available through multiple channels:

  • 24/5 live chat
  • Email and phone support
  • Extensive knowledge base and trading guides
  • Regular webinars, blogs, and market analysis

Strengths: Known for prompt responses and professional support, especially for U.S. clients.

XM

XM emphasizes education and support:

  • 24/7 customer service via live chat, email, and phone
  • Rich library of tutorials, webinars, and e-books
  • Demo accounts for practice

Strengths: Its educational resources are particularly popular among beginner traders.

Comparing Support

Both brokers score high on support quality, but Oanda’s U.S. regulatory background lends it an edge in compliance support and reliability. XM’s educational focus makes it ideal for traders seeking learning alongside trading.

Funding and Withdrawals

Oanda

  • Multiple deposit and withdrawal options, including wire transfers, credit/debit cards, and PayPal.
  • No deposit fees.
  • Withdrawals are processed promptly, within 1-2 business days.

XM

  • Offers bank transfers, credit/debit cards, Skrill, Neteller, and other e-wallets.
  • Deposit minimums vary ($5 to $50).
  • Withdrawals are typically processed within 24 hours depending on the method chosen.

Summary: Who is the Better Broker?

After exhaustively reviewing the features, trading conditions, regulation, and support services, it becomes clear that the choice depends on your specific needs and priorities.

  • Oanda is arguably the safer, more regulated choice for U.S. traders due to its long-standing regulatory commitments and clear strict compliance in the American market. It’s ideal for those seeking transparency, straightforward account structures, and regulatory peace of mind.

  • XM offers a broader range of trading instruments and account types, making it attractive for traders interested in diversify their trading portfolios beyond forex. Its competitive spreads and educational resources benefit beginners and experienced traders willing to trade unregulated entities outside the U.S., though U.S. traders should consider the regulatory aspect.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Is it legal for U.S. traders to trade with XM?

While XM accepts U.S. clients, it is not regulated in the U.S. and therefore may not fully comply with U.S. regulatory standards. U.S. traders should exercise caution and understand the risks before trading with unregulated brokers.

2. Which broker offers better educational resources?

XM is renowned for its extensive educational content, including webinars, tutorials, and articles designed for traders of all levels. Oanda provides educational material as well but is more geared toward transparency and regulatory information.

3. Can I trade cryptocurrencies with Oanda or XM?

Oanda offers cryptocurrency trading through CFDs, as does XM. However, availability varies based on jurisdiction, so U.S. traders should verify if these options are accessible in their region.

4. Which broker has better customer support?

Both brokers provide 24/5 support via various channels. Oanda’s support is often praised for professionalism and efficiency, especially for U.S. clients, while XM emphasizes responsive support with extensive educational services.

5. Are demo accounts available?

Yes, both brokers provide free demo accounts to practice trading in a risk-free environment. This is essential for new traders to familiarize themselves with trading platforms and conditions.

6. What are the deposits and withdrawal options?

Both brokers support bank transfers, credit/debit cards, and e-wallets, with Oanda leaning towards traditional methods and XM offering a broader choice of e-wallet options.

Final Thoughts

Deciding between Oanda and XM hinges on your trading goals, regulatory preferences, and the trading instruments you wish to access. For U.S. traders prioritizing regulatory safety, transparency, and reliability, Oanda is undoubtedly the better choice given its compliance with U.S. laws and proven track record. However, if you’re looking for broader product diversity, lower spreads with commissions, and extensive educational resources, XM can be appealing—though you should be mindful of its regulatory coverage outside the U.S.

Remember, choosing a broker is not just about spreads or platform features but also about trust, regulation, and the level of support you receive. Take your time to evaluate your needs, maybe open demo accounts with both brokers, and see which environment feels right for your trading style.

Your successful trading journey begins with making an informed choice. Happy trading!

Leave a Comment