FXTM vs IC Markets Compared Who is Better Broker

by

FXTM vs IC Markets: Who Is the Better Broker?

Navigating the world of online forex trading can be a daunting experience, especially when you’re faced with an array of broker options, each claiming to be the best. Among the sea of choices, FXTM (ForexTime) and IC Markets are two names that frequently emerge at the top of traders’ lists due to their reputation, services, and trading conditions. As a seasoned finance writer with a deep understanding of the forex industry, I aim to offer an impartial, comprehensive comparison between these two brokers, helping you determine which might be the better fit for your trading journey.

In this article, we will explore every critical aspect—regulation, trading platforms, spreads and commissions, account types, customer support, educational resources, and more—through an analytical and empathetic lens. Whether you’re an experienced trader seeking advanced trading tools or a newcomer trying to find a trustworthy platform, this detailed guide will equip you with the insights needed to make an informed decision.

Understanding the Foundations: About FXTM and IC Markets

Before diving into specifics, it’s essential to understand the background and core philosophies of both brokers.

FXTM (ForexTime): An Overview

FXTM is a globally recognized forex and CFD broker founded in 2011. With its headquarters in Cyprus, FXTM operates under multiple regulatory licenses, aiming to serve traders worldwide with a focus on education and trader-centric services. FXTM emphasizes accessibility, offering a variety of account types and robust educational resources to support traders of all experience levels.

IC Markets: An Overview

IC Markets, established in 2007 and based in Australia, is renowned for its technological excellence and ultra-competitive trading conditions. It is licensed and regulated primarily by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), along with other regulatory bodies in different jurisdictions. Known for its transparency, deep liquidity, and advanced trading infrastructure, IC Markets attracts more professional and institutional traders.

Regulation and Security

One of the most critical considerations when choosing a forex broker is regulation. It provides an assurance of safety, transparency, and adherence to international standards.

FXTM Regulation and Compliance

FXTM operates under several licenses, including:

  • Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) – License 185/12: Regulates their European operations.
  • FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) – UK, license no. 717270: Covers their UK clients.
  • FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) – UK, license no. 802701: For their international operations.
  • FSCA (Financial Sector Conduct Authority) – South Africa.
  • IFSC (International Financial Services Commission) — Belize.

This multi-jurisdictional licensing approach demonstrates FXTM’s commitment to regulatory compliance across regions, although some licenses, such as those in Belize, are typically considered less stringent compared to CySEC or FCA.

IC Markets Regulation and Compliance

IC Markets prides itself on being a highly transparent broker with multiple licensing arrangements:

  • ASIC (Australian Securities and Investments Commission) – License No: 335693.
  • FSA (Seychelles Financial Services Authority) — License No: SD006.
  • VFSC (Vanuatu Financial Services Commission).

ASIC regulation, being stringent, is a significant advantage for traders in terms of security and compliance with international trading standards.

Which Regulation Is Better?

While both brokers hold reputable licenses, ASIC’s regulation is generally considered more rigorous, especially for traders in terms of capital requirements, transparency, and client fund segregation.

FXTM‘s diversified licenses make it accessible for traders across jurisdictions, but traders should always verify the specific license relevant to their region.

Trading Platforms: Tools and Accessibility

The trading platform is the trader’s gateway into the markets. Ease of use, stability, and features make or break the trading experience.

FXTM Trading Platforms

FXTM offers a variety of trading platforms:

  • MetaTrader 4 (MT4): Widely regarded, user-friendly, and packed with features.
  • MetaTrader 5 (MT5): Offers additional assets, improved charting, and order management.
  • FXTM Trader App: A proprietary mobile app designed for more straightforward, on-the-go trading.
  • WebTrader: A browser-based platform allowing traders to access markets without downloading software.

FXTM’s Paltforms are known for reliability, comprehensive charting tools, expert advisors (EAs), and custom indicators.

IC Markets Trading Platforms

IC Markets specializes in providing traders with:

  • MetaTrader 4 (MT4): The industry standard, ultra-stable with a vast array of tools.
  • MetaTrader 5 (MT5): Advanced features, expanded asset classes, and better execution.
  • cTrader: Preferred by algorithmic and professional traders for its intuitive design, level II pricing, and advanced order types.
  • WebTrader: Easy access through browsers.

IC Markets’ cTrader is a crucial differentiator, appreciated for its transparency, depth of market data, and fast trade execution.

Which Platform Reigns Supreme?

Both brokers support MT4 and MT5, which are industry standards. IC Markets’ addition of cTrader provides a substantial edge for traders seeking advanced order execution, detailed market depth, and algorithmic trading.

FXTM remains competitive with its multi-platform offerings, but if you prioritize cTrader’s features, IC Markets might be the better choice.

Spreads, Commissions, and Cost of Trading

Cost efficiency is vital for optimizing trading profitability. Startlingly tight spreads and transparent fee structures can make a significant difference.

FXTM: Pricing Structure

  • Spreads:

    • Standard Accounts: Variable spreads starting from 1.3 pips for major pairs.
    • ECN Accounts: Spreads from 0.1 pip, but with a commission.

  • Commissions:

    • ECN accounts incur a per-lot commission, typically around $4 per lot.

  • Other Costs:

    • Swap/rollover fees depending on the holding position and currency pair.

IC Markets: Pricing Structure

  • Spreads:

    • Raw Spread Account: Starting from 0.0 pips on major pairs.
    • Standard Account: Around 1.0 pip spreads.
    • CTrader ECN: Spreads from 0.0 pips with competitive commissions.

  • Commissions:

    • For ECN accounts, commissions are usually $3.50 per lot, lower than many competitors.

  • Other Costs:

    • Swap fees applicable depending on the instrument.

Which Is Cost-Effective?

IC Markets generally offers lower spreads, especially on ECN accounts, which are ideal for high-frequency traders and scalpers. Their commission structure is also more competitive, making them appealing for cost-conscious traders.

FXTM’s spreads, while competitive, are slightly wider, but they compensate with a broader selection of account types designed for different trader profiles.

Account Types and Suitability

The choice of account type can significantly affect trading comfort, costs, and strategies.

FXTM Account Options

  • Standard Account:

    • No commission.
    • Wider spreads (~1.3 pips).
    • Suitable for beginner traders or those preferring simplicity.

  • ECN Account:

    • Tight spreads from 0.1 pip.
    • $6 per lot commission (sometimes lower, depending on location).
    • Best for experienced traders, scalpers, and algorithmic traders.

  • Shares Account:

    • For trading CFDs on stocks.

IC Markets Account Options

  • Standard Account:

    • No commissions.
    • Spreads from ~1.0 pip.
    • Suitable for less active traders.

  • Raw Spread (ECN) Account:

    • Spreads from 0.0 pips.
    • $3.50 per lot commission.
    • Ideal for high-volume and professional traders.

  • cTrader ECN Account:

    • Similar conditions to the raw spread account but with cTrader platform features.

Which Account Best Fits Your Style?

If you are a beginner or prefer simplicity, FXTM’s Standard account offers an accessible entry point.

If you’re an experienced, active, or professional trader, IC Markets’ ECN accounts provide a cost-effective setup, especially with their lower spreads and commissions.

Customer Support and Educational Resources

Customer service quality and educational support can significantly influence your trading experience, particularly when encountering issues or seeking to improve skills.

FXTM’s Support & Resources

  • Customer Support:

    • 24/5 multilingual support via live chat, email, and phone.
    • Excellent in many regions, with dedicated account managers.

  • Educational Resources:

    • Robust material including webinars, e-books, trading guides, and tutorials.
    • Regular market analysis and trading signals.
    • Trader qualification assessments.

  • Additional Features:

    • Demo accounts.
    • Trading academy aimed at beginner traders.

IC Markets’ Support & Resources

  • Customer Support:

    • 24/7 multilingual support via live chat, email, and phone.
    • Known for quick response times and professionalism.

  • Educational Resources:

    • Limited but adequate library with articles, webinars, and guides.
    • Market analysis updates and trading news.

  • Additional Features:

    • Demo accounts.
    • Trading tools and APIs for advanced traders.

Which Support Is Better?

IC Markets is often praised for its prompt customer service and professional support staff, particularly appealing to seasoned traders.

FXTM scores high on educational support, catering well to traders seeking to learn and improve their skills.

Deposit & Withdrawal Options and Funding Flexibility

Ease of deposits and withdrawals is essential for smooth trading operations.

FXTM

  • Methods:

    • Bank wire transfer, credit/debit cards, E-wallets like Skrill, Neteller, and WebMoney.

  • Processing Time:

    • Instant to 24 hours for e-wallets; bank transfers may take longer.

  • Deposit Minimums:

    • Varies by account type; often around $10–$50.

IC Markets

  • Methods:

    • Bank transfers, credit/debit cards, PayPal, Neteller, Skrill, PoliticPay.

  • Processing Time:

    • Usually instant for e-wallets; bank transfers may take 1-3 days.

  • Deposit Minimums:

    • Starting at $200, though some methods may require higher minimums.

Which Broker Is More Flexible?

FXTM tends to have lower minimum deposit requirements, which is advantageous for beginners or small traders.

IC Markets’ higher minimum deposit is more suited for traders ready to commit larger capital and seeking cost efficiencies via advanced trading.

Trading Conditions for Specific Instruments

Both brokers offer access to a range of instruments, but differences exist.

FXTM

  • Forex Pairs: Over 60 currency pairs.
  • CFDs: Indices, commodities, stocks, cryptocurrencies.
  • Crypto Trading: Available but with added spreads/fees.

IC Markets

  • Forex Pairs: Over 60.
  • CFDs: Commodities, indices, stocks, cryptocurrencies.
  • Forex Focus: Particularly known for deep liquidity and tight spreads on Forex.

Conclusion on Instruments

Both brokers offer extensive instrument selections, but IC Markets’ focus on deep liquidity and competitive spreads makes it particularly attractive for forex traders.

Transparency and Reliability: What Do Traders Say?

Reviews and trader feedback can provide genuine insights into a broker’s reliability.

  • FXTM has a broad global presence, with a generally positive reputation for educational support but occasionally faced criticism over withdrawal issues in certain regions.

  • IC Markets is lauded for transparency, fast execution speeds, and reliable service, especially appreciated by professional traders.

Final Verdict: Which Broker Comes Out On Top?

The choice hinges largely on your individual trading style, capital, experience level, and priorities:

  • Choose FXTM if:

    • You prioritize comprehensive education and support.
    • You’re a beginner needing a straightforward platform.
    • You prefer diverse account options for different trading needs.
    • You operate from regions where FXTM’s licenses are favorable.

  • Choose IC Markets if:

    • You are a professional or high-frequency trader seeking tight spreads and low commissions.
    • You value advanced trading platforms like cTrader.
    • You prioritize transparency and fast, reliable execution.
    • You are comfortable depositing larger minimum amounts for better trading conditions.

In essence, both brokers are reputable, but they cater to slightly different segments of traders. Your decision should align with your trading goals, experience, and risk appetite.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q1: Are FXTM and IC Markets regulated by the same authority?
A: No. FXTM operates under multiple licenses across different jurisdictions, including CySEC and FCA, while IC Markets is primarily regulated by ASIC in Australia, which is considered one of the strictest regulatory bodies in the industry.

Q2: Which broker offers tighter spreads?
A: IC Markets generally offers tighter spreads, especially on their ECN accounts, making them more suitable for cost-conscious and professional traders.

Q3: Which platform is better for algorithmic trading?
A: Both brokers support MT4 and MT5, designed for algorithmic trading. Additionally, IC Markets’ cTrader is favored by many algorithmic traders for its advanced features.

Q4: Are there any deposit fees?
A: Both brokers may charge fees depending on the deposit method. FXTM generally has lower minimum deposits, while IC Markets may require higher initial funding.

Q5: Which broker is better for beginners?
A: FXTM, with its educational resources, user-friendly account options, and lower entry barriers, is often recommended for novice traders.

Q6: Can traders from the US use FXTM or IC Markets?
A: FXTM’s services are limited or unavailable for US traders due to regulatory restrictions, while IC Markets does not accept US clients. Always verify current eligibility before opening an account.

Final Words

Choosing the right forex broker is a critical step towards your trading success. Both FXTM and IC Markets are robust, legitimate, and well-respected in the industry, but their appeal varies based on your trading needs.

If your focus is on cost-efficiency, professional-grade tools, and deep liquidity, IC Markets stands out as the better choice. Conversely, if you’re starting out, value educational support, and prefer a straightforward trading experience, FXTM offers compelling advantages.

Remember, no single broker is perfect for everyone. Take the time to consider your trading style, risk tolerance, and financial goals before making your decision. And always practice with demo accounts, understand the fee structures, and ensure your broker’s regulation aligns with your safety expectations.

Your journey into forex trading is a marathon, not a sprint. Pick a broker that not only offers competitive conditions but also supports your growth and security as a trader.

I hope this comprehensive comparison helps illuminate the nuanced differences between FXTM and IC Markets. As you embark or continue on your trading journey, prioritize transparency, regulation, cost, and platform features, and you’ll be well-positioned to succeed.

Leave a Comment