FXCM vs FXTM Compared Who is Better Broker

by

FXCM vs FXTM Compared: Who is the Better Broker?

Navigating the crowded landscape of forex brokers can be daunting, especially when you’re looking for a reliable partner to support your trading journey. Among the myriad options, FXCM and FXTM emerge as prominent players, each claiming to offer the best trading experience. But how do they truly compare? Which broker aligns better with your trading style, needs, and goals? In this comprehensive analysis, we’ll delve into every aspect that matters—from regulation and trading conditions to platform features and customer support—to help you make an informed decision.

Introduction

Trading forex and CFDs opens a gateway to countless opportunities, yet success depends heavily on choosing a broker that fits your personal requirements. The reputation, stability, regulatory oversight, and the quality of services are crucial factors. Both FXCM and FXTM have built solid reputations over the years—serving thousands of traders worldwide. However, their core offerings, fee structures, platforms, and customer experiences differ substantially.

To truly understand who might be the better broker for you, let’s explore their origins, licensing, trading conditions, and client service meticulously. Remember, selecting a broker isn’t just about the lowest spreads or the highest bonuses; it’s about trust, transparency, and how well the broker aligns with your trading style.

Background and Corporate Overview

FXCM – A Legacy in Forex Trading

Founded in 1999, FXCM (Forex Capital Markets) has established itself as a pioneer in the online forex trading space. Based in the United States, FXCM has historically been known for its innovative approach, technological prowess, and focus on transparency. Although it faced regulatory hurdles in the past—most notably the lawsuit and subsequent closure of its US operations—FXCM today continues to operate in multiple jurisdictions through different entities.

FXTM – A Rapidly Growing Global Broker

FXTM (Forextime) is comparatively younger but has experienced dramatic growth since its inception in 2011. It is headquartered in Cyprus and is regulated by several authorities, including the Cypriot CySEC, the UK’s FCA, and others, emphasizing its commitment to compliance and investor protection. FXTM positions itself as a broker for retail traders, providing extensive educational resources and a diverse range of trading instruments.

Regulation and Safety of Funds

FXCM Regulation and Compliance

FXCM’s regulatory environment has seen significant fluctuations. Its US entity was closed in 2017 due to regulatory issues, and now, FXCM operates primarily in Europe and certain other regions through subsidiaries like Forex Capital Markets Limited regulated by CySEC.

  • Regulatory Bodies:

    • CySEC (Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission)
    • FCA (UK’s Financial Conduct Authority) for certain regional entities
    • ASIC (Australian Securities and Investments Commission) for Australian clients

  • Client Fund Segregation:

    • FXCM maintains segregated accounts, adhering to strict security protocols to protect client funds.

  • Investor Compensation Schemes:

    • Clients in Cyprus benefit from the Investor Compensation Fund, covering eligible claims up to €20,000.

FXTM Regulation and Investor Protection

FXTM operates under several licenses, offering a multi-jurisdictional safety net for clients.

  • Regulatory Bodies:

    • CySEC (Cyprus)
    • FCA (UK)
    • FSC (Mauritius)
    • FSCA (South Africa)

  • Client Fund Segregation:

    • Client funds are held separately from company operational funds, ensuring safety during financial upheavals.

  • Negative Balance Protection:

    • FXTM provides this feature globally, preventing traders from losing more than their account balance.

Summary: While both brokers operate under reputable regulators, FXTM’s multi-jurisdictional licensing offers more comprehensive protection, especially considering its regulatory oversight by FCA and other top-tier authorities.

Trading Platforms and Technology

FXCM Trading Platforms

FXCM primarily offers its proprietary platform, Trading Station, along with compatibility for MetaTrader 4 (MT4).

  • Trading Station:
    • User-friendly interface with advanced charting.
    • Rich analytical tools.
    • Automated trading capabilities.
  • MetaTrader 4:
    • Standard popular platform, supports custom indicators and Expert Advisors (EAs).

Additional Features:

  • Mobile version for Android and iOS.
  • Web-based platform.

FXTM Trading Platforms

FXTM excels in offering multiple platforms tailored to different trader needs.

  • MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and MetaTrader 5 (MT5):
    • Widely regarded for their stability and vast indicator ecosystem.
    • Available on desktop, web, and mobile.
    • Supports algorithmic trading.
  • FXTM Invest:
    • Copy trading and social trading platform.
  • FXTM Trader App:
    • User-friendly mobile trading experience.

Unique Offerings:

  • FXTM’s platforms are praised for their seamless operation and variety, accommodating both novice and advanced traders.

Which Platform Is Better?

Both brokers deploy MT4, the industry-leading platform for forex trading. FXCM’s proprietary platform, Trading Station, offers advanced tools suited for technical traders, whereas FXTM’s multi-platform approach provides more choices to fit different trading styles.

Range of Instruments and Markets

Forex and CFD Offerings

Broker Forex Pairs Indices Commodities Shares Cryptocurrencies
FXCM Over 40 Yes Yes Limited No, but CFDs on cryptocurrencies are available via third-party integrations
FXTM Over 50 Yes Yes Yes Yes

Other Instruments and Trading Options

  • FXCM focuses heavily on forex and indices, less on shares or commodities.
  • FXTM offers a broader range, including shares CFDs and cryptocurrencies, making it appealing for diversifying portfolios.

Trade Variety Impact:

If your trading is focused solely on forex and indices, FXCM’s specialization might suffice. However, for traders interested in stocks, commodities, or cryptocurrencies, FXTM provides a more diversified trading universe.

Trading Conditions: Spreads, Leverage, and Commissions

Spreads and Commissions

Broker Typical Spread on EUR/USD Commission Notes
FXCM Starting around 1.3 pips None (raw spreads can be lower with direct ECN) Variable spreads depending on account type
FXTM 0.1 to 1 pip for ECN accounts Yes ECN accounts feature tight spreads, plus commissions

Leverage Offered

  • FXCM:
    • Leverage varies regionally, typically up to 1:30 for retail traders in the U.S. (for ongoing compliance).
    • Higher leverage up to 1:400 available in other regions for professional traders.
  • FXTM:
    • Offers leverage up to 1:1000 in some regions, though European clients are limited to 1:30 (per regulatory requirements).

Impact of Trading Costs

  • FXCM:
    • Simpler fee model—spread-based with no commissions on standard accounts.
    • ECN accounts feature lower spreads with a per-lot commission.
  • FXTM:
    • Multiple account types, with ECN accounts offering minimal spreads and per-trade commissions.
    • More transparency on trading costs.

Which Is Cheaper?

For very tight spreads and low trading costs, especially for high-frequency traders, FXTM’s ECN accounts tend to be more cost-effective due to narrower spreads and competitive commissions.

Account Types and Minimum Deposits

FXCM Account Types

  • Standard Account:
    • No commission, spreads start at around 1.3 pips.
    • Minimum deposit: $50.
  • Active Trader Account:
    • For high-volume traders, offers reduced spreads.
    • Minimum deposit: $25,000.
  • FXCM Pro:
    • Institutional and high-net-worth clients.

FXTM Account Types

  • Standard Account:
    • Spreads from 1 pip.
    • No commission.
    • Minimum deposit: $10.
  • ECN Account:
    • Spreads from 0.1 pip.
    • Commission applies.
    • Minimum deposit: $200.

Summary: FXTM provides more flexible options suited for beginners, while FXCM’s accounts favor traders with larger deposits or institutional preferences.

Customer Support and Educational Resources

FXCM Customer Support

  • Provides support via phone, chat, and email.
  • 24/5 support in most regions.
  • History of on-boarding robust training tools, webinars, and analysis.

FXTM Customer Support

  • Dedicated support with multilingual options.
  • 24/5 live chat, phone, and email.
  • Offers detailed educational resources, trading tutorials, webinars, and market analyses.

Educational Resources

FXTM invests heavily in education—comprehensive guides, video tutorials, webinars, and a trading academy—ideal for improving trading skills.

FXCM also offers educational materials but leans more towards technical analysis and market news.

Which Is Better?

FXTM’s educational infrastructure is more extensive, making it particularly suitable for beginners seeking to learn.

User Experience and Platform Reliability

Both brokers boast user-friendly interfaces, but their platform stability and speed vary depending on regional infrastructure.

  • FXCM:
    • Known for its proprietary platform’s stability.
    • Offers advanced features for technical traders.
  • FXTM:
    • Slight edge in mobile and web applications’ user experience.
    • High platform uptime with cloud-based technology.

Fees for Deposits, Withdrawals, and Inactivity

Both brokers have transparent fee policies but differ in certain aspects:

  • FXCM:
    • No deposit or withdrawal fees for bank transfers.
    • Withdrawal process can sometimes be slow.
  • FXTM:
    • Free deposits via e-wallets and bank transfer.
    • Some withdrawal methods may incur charges depending on currency and method.
    • Inactivity fee applied after 12 months of no activity.

Pros and Cons: FXCM vs FXTM

FXCM

Pros:

  • Long-standing reputation with a history of innovation.
  • Strong regulation outside the US.
  • Proprietary platform with advanced analytical tools.
  • Good liquidity and execution speed.

Cons:

  • Limited product range compared to FXTM.
  • Higher minimum deposits for certain accounts.
  • Past legal issues in the US affecting trust for some traders.

FXTM

Pros:

  • Regulation in multiple reputable jurisdictions.
  • Diverse product offerings including equities and cryptocurrencies.
  • Low minimum deposit requirements.
  • Extensive educational resources.

Cons:

  • Higher trading costs on standard accounts.
  • Inconsistent platform stability reported in some regions.
  • Can be complex for absolute beginners due to multiple account options.

Final Thoughts: Who Is the Better Broker?

Choosing the ideal broker depends entirely on your personal trading profile.

  • If you are a professional trader or have substantial capital: FXCM’s advanced analytical tools and reputation might appeal more, especially if you seek stability and proprietary platforms.

  • If you’re a beginner or an active trader looking for variety: FXTM’s broader range of instruments, educational resources, and flexible account options make it a more inviting choice.

Ultimately, the decision hinges on examining your goals, risk appetite, and preferences for trading instruments, costs, and educational support.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Which broker offers better regulation—FXCM or FXTM?

FXTM has multiple licenses from regulators like CySEC and FCA, providing a higher level of regulatory safety assurance. FXCM’s regulation is more regional, and its US operations no longer exist.

2. Are spreads lower with FXCM or FXTM?

Typically, FXTM’s ECN accounts offer tighter spreads, especially during peak hours, while FXCM’s spreads are competitive but slightly wider.

3. Which broker provides better educational resources?

FXTM is renowned for comprehensive educational tools, tutorials, and webinars suitable for beginners. FXCM also offers resources but leans towards technical analysis.

4. Can I trade cryptocurrencies with FXCM and FXTM?

  • FXCM offers CFDs on cryptocurrencies via third-party providers.
  • FXTM provides a broader range of cryptocurrencies directly via its trading platform.

5. Which broker is more suitable for beginners?

FXTM generally is better suited due to its lower minimum deposits, educational resources, and account options.

6. Do both brokers provide negative balance protection?

Yes, both brokers offer negative balance protection—crucial for retail traders—preventing traders from owing more than their account balance.

7. Are there any significant withdrawal fees?

Withdrawal fees vary by method and region but are generally minimal or absent for bank transfers at both brokers. Always check your regional policies.

Conclusion

The choice between FXCM and FXTM ultimately boils down to your individual trading style and needs. FXCM excels in its technological offerings and solid reputation, especially for experienced traders who prioritize stability and a proprietary platform. Meanwhile, FXTM shines with a broader instrument range, competitive pricing, and outstanding educational support—ideal for newer traders or those seeking diversification.

Both brokers are reputable, regulated, and offer robust features. Careful consideration of stipulated trading conditions, costs, and support services will guide you toward the best choice for your forex trading journey. Remember, the best broker is the one that aligns with your goals, offers transparent pricing, and provides a secure trading environment.

Happy trading, and always trade responsibly!

Leave a Comment