FXTM vs XM Compared Who is Better Broker

by

FXTM vs XM: Who Is the Better Broker?

Navigating the landscape of forex brokers can be overwhelming, especially with an abundance of options saturated in the market. Whether you’re a seasoned trader or just starting, choosing the right broker is foundational to your trading success. Among the popular choices are FXTM (ForexTime) and XM, both of which have cultivated sizable global client bases thanks to their trading tools, educational resources, and regulatory credentials.

In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll explore every facet of these brokers—from their regulation and trading platforms to account types, spreads, commissions, customer support, and overall reputation. Our goal is to offer you an honest, detailed perspective, helping you determine which platform aligns best with your trading needs and goals.

Introduction to FXTM and XM

Before delving into specific comparisons, it’s crucial to understand the background and core structures of both brokers.

FXTM (ForexTime)

Founded in 2011, FXTM has quickly established itself as a prominent forex broker with offices in multiple jurisdictions, including the UK, Cyprus, and South Africa. Known for its strong educational offerings and diverse account types, FXTM caters to both retail traders and institutional clients.

XM

Founded in 2009, XM has grown into a globally recognized broker with a presence in over 130 countries. Its reputation rests on competitive spreads, extensive educational resources, and a multi-asset trading platform that extends beyond forex to include CFDs on commodities, indices, and cryptocurrencies.

Regulation and Legal Standing

Regulatory oversight is pivotal as it assures traders of the broker’s adherence to strict industry standards and the safety of client funds.

FXTM Regulation

  • UK (FCA): A subset of FXTM operates under the Financial Conduct Authority, which is highly reputable worldwide.
  • CySEC (Cyprus): Most of FXTM’s operations are regulated by the Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission, complying with MiFID II.
  • FSCA (South Africa): FXTM Africa is regulated by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority.
  • Other Jurisdictions: FXTM also holds licenses in some African countries, with a focus on regional compliance.

Implication for Traders: FXTM’s multiple regulatory licenses signify a commitment to transparency and financial security, though some European regulators, like CySEC, are considered less stringent than the FCA.

XM Regulation

  • ASIC (Australia): XM Australia is regulated by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, a highly respected authority.
  • CySEC (Cyprus): XM Cyprus is regulated by CySEC, similar to FXTM.
  • IFSC (Belize): Also licensed by the International Financial Services Commission, though this license is often viewed as less rigorous compared to other regulators.
  • Other jurisdictions: XM holds additional licenses in various jurisdictions, but the primary and most reputable ones are ASIC and CySEC.

Implication for Traders: XM’s regulation by ASIC and CySEC gives it a strong regulatory standing, especially for traders in regions where these jurisdictions are viewed as credible.

Summary of Regulatory Credentials

Broker Main Regulators Strengths Considerations
FXTM FCA, CySEC, FSCA Multiple strong licenses Slight variability in regulatory rigor
XM ASIC, CySEC Reputable authorities Additional licenses less rigorous

Trading Platforms & Technology

The platform available to traders is a vital aspect of their overall experience, influencing ease of trading, execution speed, and analytical capabilities.

FXTM Trading Platforms

  • MetaTrader 4 (MT4): The industry standard, offering extensive charting tools, automated trading, and a user-friendly interface.
  • MetaTrader 5 (MT5): The successor to MT4, providing more timeframes, order types, and integrated economic calendars. FXTM offers both MT4 and MT5 across various account types.
  • Mobile Trading: Both platforms are available via iOS and Android apps, optimized for seamless mobile experience.
  • WebTrader: FXTM also provides an HTML5 web platform for quick access without software downloads.

XM Trading Platforms

  • MetaTrader 4 & MetaTrader 5: Like FXTM, XM provides both MT4 and MT5 platforms, making it flexible for traders preferring different trading environments.
  • Mobile Apps: Android and iOS apps are feature-rich, supporting full trading functionalities on the go.
  • WebTrader: Available with an intuitive interface, complementing the desktop versions.

Additional Technology Features

  • Automated Trading: Both brokers facilitate Expert Advisors (EAs) and algorithmic trading via MetaTrader platforms.
  • Trading Tools & Indicators: Extensive charting tools, customizable indicators, and economic calendars are integrated within both platforms.
  • Order Execution: Both brokers boast fast, reliable order execution, with execution types varying between brokers depending on account type.

Account Types, Minimum Deposits, & Spreads

The balance between flexibility, cost, and trading conditions defines the overall appeal of a broker’s account offerings.

FXTM Account Types

  • Standard Account: No commission, spreads start from 1.3 pips.
  • ECN Account: Commission-based, spreads from 0.1 pip, suitable for high-volume traders.
  • FXTM Invest: Social trading platform allowing copying of professional traders.
  • Demo Accounts: Available for practice with virtual funds.

Minimum Deposit: Typically $10 to $500 depending on the account type and jurisdiction.

XM Account Types

  • Standard Account: No commission, spreads from 1.0 pip.
  • Micro Account: Designed for smaller traders, spreads similar to Standard.
  • XM Ultra Low: Spreads as low as 0.6 pips with commission.
  • Demo Accounts: Offered with virtual funds for testing strategies.

Minimum Deposit: Usually $5 to $50 for standard accounts.

Spread & Commission Comparison

Broker Typical Spread (EUR/USD) Commission Notes
FXTM From 1.3 pips (Standard) / 0.1 pip (ECN) ECN accounts incur $4 per lot per side Wide range of accounts
XM From 1.0 pip (Standard) / 0.6 pips (Ultra Low) $5 – $7 per lot (Ultra Low) Competitive spreads generally

Fee Structure Insights

  • FXTM tends to have slightly wider spreads on standard accounts but offers ECN options for lower spreads at a cost.
  • XM positions itself as a low-cost broker with tight spreads, particularly on Ultra Low accounts, but charges commissions.

Trading Conditions & Execution Speeds

Fast, reliable execution is essential in forex trading to avoid slippage and unfavorable prices.

FXTM Performance

  • Execution Type: ECN and STP execution models.
  • Average Execution Speed: Around 0.1 to 0.2 seconds with ECN accounts.
  • Slippage & Requotes: Generally low, especially on ECN accounts.

XM Performance

  • Execution Type: ECN and market execution.
  • Average Speed: Around 0.2 to 0.3 seconds.
  • Slippage & Requotes: Minimal, with tight spreads supporting quick execution.

Reliability & Slippage

Both brokers employ advanced trading infrastructure with high-quality liquidity providers. Traders report good execution consistency, although market volatility can influence slippage regardless of broker robustness.

Customer Support & Educational Resources

Excellent customer service often distinguishes reputable brokers, especially for newer traders.

FXTM Support & Resources

  • Customer Support: Multi-channel availability including live chat, email, and phone support.
  • Languages: Support in over 20 languages, including English.
  • Educational Material: Extensive blog, webinars, video tutorials, e-books, and trading guides aimed at all experience levels.
  • Research & Analysis: Daily market analysis, economic calendars, and trading signals.

XM Support & Resources

  • Customer Support: 24/5 live chat, email, and telephone support.
  • Languages: Support in multiple languages.
  • Educational Content: Rich library of webinars, tutorials, glossary, and market news.
  • Community & Forums: Active community forums and regular webinars often led by industry experts.

Service Issue Handling

Both brokers have received positive feedback for prompt customer service, though individual experiences naturally vary.

Promotions, Bonuses & Transparency

Bonus offers are a common marketing tactic but should be approached carefully, considering their impact on withdrawal and trading conditions.

FXTM Promotions

  • Occasional deposit bonuses and trading contests.
  • Clear transparency about bonus terms and conditions.
  • Focus on transparency to prevent misinterpretation of bonus restrictions.

XM Promotions

  • Regular deposit bonuses and trading contests.
  • Transparency about bonus terms.
  • No deposit bonuses in some regions due to regulatory restrictions.

Note: Many jurisdictions, especially the US, restrict such bonuses. Always check regional regulations before participating.

Deposit & Withdrawal Methods

Ease of funding your account is critical, especially for traders in the US.

FXTM

  • Methods: Bank transfer, credit/debit cards, e-wallets including Skrill, Neteller, and local bank options.
  • Processing Time: Usually immediate to 24 hours, depending on method.
  • Fees: Variable, generally low or waived for certain deposit methods.

XM

  • Methods: Similar to FXTM—bank transfers, cards, e-wallets.
  • Processing Time: Instant to 24 hours.
  • Fees: Usually minimal or none.

US-specific Considerations

  • Neither FXTM nor XM offers US-based accounts or US residents’ trading services due to regulatory restrictions. US traders should consider brokers operating under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).

Overall Reputation & Trader Feedback

Assessing a broker’s reputation can significantly influence your trading confidence.

FXTM Reputation

  • Recognized for excellent customer service and educational content.
  • Generally positive reviews regarding platform stability and execution.
  • Some complaints about spreads on standard accounts and withdrawal delays, but these are typical in the industry.

XM Reputation

  • Known for low spreads and extensive educational resources.
  • Solid reputation for customer support.
  • Occasional critiques regarding account verification processes and withdrawal issues.

Final note: Both brokers are considered reputable and reliable, with minor complaints typical of industry feedback.

Pros and Cons Summary

FXTM

Pros:

  • Regulated in multiple jurisdictions.
  • Strong educational resources.
  • Multiple account types including ECN.
  • High-quality MT4 and MT5 platforms.

Cons:

  • Slightly wider spreads on standard accounts.
  • Regulatory variations may affect trader security.

XM

Pros:

  • Competitive spreads, especially on Ultra Low accounts.
  • Regulated by ASIC and CySEC.
  • Rich educational content.
  • Multiple assets beyond forex.

Cons:

  • Additional licenses less rigorous.
  • Limited deposit bonuses in some regions.

Conclusion: Which Broker Is Better?

Choosing between FXTM and XM ultimately depends on your specific trading style, risk appetite, and strategic preferences.

  • If you value strict regulation and a broad choice of trading accounts, including ECN options, FXTM may appeal more. Its multiple licenses and advanced trading tools make it suitable for professional traders and those seeking transparency.

  • If tight spreads, extensive educational resources, and a simple account structure are your priorities, XM may be the better fit. Its strong regulatory credentials, especially in Australia and Europe, enhance its credibility.

Both brokers are reputable, well-established, and capable of supporting traders in achieving their financial aspirations. The decision hinges on aligning their offerings with your individual needs.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Are FXTM and XM regulated brokers?

Yes. FXTM is regulated by authorities such as the FCA, CySEC, and FSCA, whereas XM holds licenses from ASIC, CySEC, and other jurisdictions. Both brokers adhere to stringent regulatory standards, though the strength of licenses varies.

2. Can US residents trade with FXTM or XM?

No, generally US residents cannot open accounts with FXTM or XM due to strict US regulations around forex trading. US traders should explore brokers regulated by the SEC or CFTC, such as Interactive Brokers or Forex.com.

3. Which broker offers better educational resources?

Both brokers excel in education. FXTM is renowned for its comprehensive webinars, tutorials, and market analyses. XM also provides extensive educational content, including video tutorials and regular webinars.

4. Which broker has lower trading costs?

XM typically offers tighter spreads, especially on its Ultra Low accounts, making it more cost-effective for traders focused on low-cost trading. FXTM‘s ECN accounts also have competitive spreads but involve commissions.

5. Are the platforms offered by FXTM and XM user-friendly?

Yes. Both brokers focus on the MetaTrader suite, which is industry-standard with a user-friendly interface, advanced analytical tools, and automated trading support.

6. What are the main differences in account types?

  • FXTM: Offers Standard, ECN, Shares, and Invest accounts.
  • XM: Provides Standard, Micro, and Ultra Low accounts, with options for more customized trading conditions.

7. Do both brokers support automated trading?

Absolutely. Both brokers support MetaTrader EAs and algorithmic trading functionalities.

Final Thoughts

In the world of forex trading, choosing a trustworthy broker is pivotal. FXTM and XM are both industry giants with robust regulations, competitive trading conditions, and rich educational support. Your choice should align with your trading goals, experience level, and preferences for platform features.

Does your trading style lean towards ECN execution, or are low spreads more appealing? Are educational resources a high priority? Do regulation and transparency influence your decision? Reflecting on these questions can help you select the right partner for your forex journey.

Remember, the best broker for someone else might not be the best for you. Take advantage of demo accounts to test their platforms and services before committing real funds. In the end, informed choices backed by thorough research will serve as the foundation for your trading success.

Leave a Comment