AvaTrade vs Interactive Brokers Compared Who is Better Broker

by

AvaTrade vs Interactive Brokers: Who Is the Better Broker?

Choosing the right broker is a fundamental step toward achieving your financial goals, whether you’re a seasoned investor or just starting your journey in trading and investing. The landscape is vast, with numerous platforms vying for your attention, each offering different features, fee structures, and user experiences. Among the many choices, AvaTrade and Interactive Brokers stand out as two of the most prominent and reputable names in the industry.

But how do they compare? Which broker is better suited to your trading style, financial objectives, and experience level? This comprehensive guide aims to dissect these two giants side-by-side—exploring their history, offerings, fees, platforms, and customer service—to help you make an informed decision.

Let’s begin by diving into their backgrounds, core features, and what sets each apart.

The Backgrounds of AvaTrade and Interactive Brokers

Who Is AvaTrade?

Founded in 2006, AvaTrade is a globally recognized broker specializing primarily in forex and CFD trading. With headquarters in Dublin, Ireland, the firm has established a presence in multiple countries and is regulated by several leading financial authorities, including the Central Bank of Ireland, ASIC (Australia), and FSCA (South Africa).

AvaTrade’s core focus has always been on providing accessible trading options to retail investors across the world, offering a diverse selection of assets such as forex, cryptocurrencies, commodities, indices, and stocks through CFDs.

Strengths of AvaTrade:

  • Extensive asset offerings, with a strong emphasis on forex and CFDs
  • User-friendly trading platforms suitable for beginners
  • Robust educational resources
  • Regulation across multiple jurisdictions

Who Is Interactive Brokers?

Founded in 1978 by Thomas Peterffy, Interactive Brokers (IBKR) is a venerable player in the online trading space, headquartered in Greenwich, Connecticut. IBKR is often considered the gold standard among professional traders and institutional investors, owing to its comprehensive offerings, low-cost structure, and advanced technology.

IBKR is regulated by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), among other agencies. It provides access to a broad array of global markets, including stocks, options, futures, forex, bonds, ETFs, and more.

Strengths of Interactive Brokers:

  • Ultra-low commissions and tight spreads
  • Access to over 135 global markets
  • Highly advanced trading tools and APIs
  • Suitable for professional traders and institutional investors

Core Offerings and Asset Classes

Asset Selection & Market Access

AvaTrade is primarily known for:

  • Forex trading
  • CFDs (Contracts for Difference) on stocks, commodities, indices, cryptocurrencies
  • Limited access to direct stock trading for some clients via partnerships

While AvaTrade offers a rich array of CFDs and forex pairs, it does not provide direct access to individual securities in the U.S. stock market for retail clients.

Interactive Brokers offers:

  • Direct access to over 135 global markets
  • Extensive asset class coverage: stocks, options, futures, forex, bonds, funds, ETFs, and more
  • A particularly attractive platform for access to U.S. equities and derivatives

Market Access Comparison:

Feature AvaTrade Interactive Brokers
Forex Trading Extensive Available; via specialized platform
CFDs Yes Yes
Stocks & ETFs Limited for retail clients Full access in multiple markets
Futures & Options Limited (mainly CFDs) Very extensive; worldwide coverage
Cryptocurrency Yes, via CFDs and some direct trades Yes, via dedicated crypto platform

Summary:
If your focus is predominantly forex and CFDs with a more straightforward experience, AvaTrade suits well. For traders seeking a comprehensive and direct access to stocks, options, futures, and global markets, Interactive Brokers is the more formidable choice.

Fee Structures and Costs

Understanding fee structures is crucial because costs eat into returns over time.

AvaTrade Fees

  • Spreads: Typically competitive, with EUR/USD spreads around 0.9 pips (may vary depending on account type and market conditions).
  • Commissions: Mostly CFD-based, with no commissions on forex trades; some commission-based offerings for stock trading.
  • Overnight Fees: Applicable, generally based on interest rate differentials.
  • Deposit & Withdrawal Fees: Free for most methods, but some charges may apply depending on the region and payment method.
  • Inactivity Fees: May be charged if an account remains dormant for extended periods.

Interactive Brokers Fees

  • Commissions: Very low—stock trades from $0.005 per share, with minimums and different fee tiers based on volume; futures from roughly $1.50 per contract.
  • Spreads & Markups: Tight spreads, especially in forex and futures.
  • Forex Fees: Spreads as low as 0.2 pip, with a small commission.
  • Account minimums: $0 for IBKR Lite in the U.S., but preferred accounts may require a minimum.
  • Additional Fees: Data subscription costs, withdrawal fees for some methods, and inactivity fees (depending on account type).

Cost Comparison Summary:

Fee Aspect AvaTrade Interactive Brokers
Typical spreads / commissions Moderate, CFD-focused Very low, competitive mainstream fees
Stock trading fees Varies; some commissions, some zero-cost From $0.005/share or equivalent in futures
Currency trading (Forex) Spreads from 0.9 pips, no commission Spreads from 0.2 pip, small commission
Platform & data fees Free to use, some data costs Low or free, model-dependent
Inactivity fees Yes, for dormant accounts Yes, for inactive accounts; waived under certain conditions

Bottom Line:
For cost-sensitive traders, Interactive Brokers generally offers a more economical solution across most asset classes, especially for high-volume traders.

Trading Platforms & User Experience

AvaTrade Platforms

  • MetaTrader 4 (MT4): The industry-standard platform, highly customizable, with social trading and Expert Advisors (EAs).
  • AvaTradeGo: The proprietary mobile app, intuitive and designed for ease of use.
  • WebTrader: Browser-based, accessible, and user-friendly, suitable for beginners.
  • Automated Trading: Supports EAs on MT4 and MT5.

AvaTrade’s Strengths: User-friendly interfaces, easy onboarding, with ample educational content for beginners.

Interactive Brokers Platforms

  • Trader Workstation (TWS): A highly advanced platform suited for professional traders. It offers extensive customization, complex order types, and real-time analytics.
  • Client Portal: An easier interface for less experienced traders, web-based.
  • IBKR Mobile: Mobile app offering most features of TWS.
  • APIs & Automations: Supports extensive API integrations for algo trading.

IBKR’s Strengths: Professional-grade tools, extensive customization options, powerful analytics, suitable for active and institutional traders.

User Experience & Accessibility

While AvaTrade offers straightforward, beginner-friendly platforms with a focus on ease of use, Interactive Brokers caters more to experienced traders seeking sophisticated trading tools. The learning curve with IBKR can be steep, but the platform rewards effort with unmatched capabilities.

Regulation, Security & Customer Support

AvaTrade

  • Regulated By: Central Bank of Ireland, ASIC, FSA (South Africa), FSP (New Zealand)
  • Segregated Accounts: Yes
  • Investor Compensation: Varies by jurisdiction
  • Customer Support: Multilingual support via phone, email, live chat, available 24/5 or 24/7 in some regions

Interactive Brokers

  • Regulated By: SEC, FINRA, FCA, ASIC, MiFID, and others
  • Segregated Accounts: Yes
  • Investor Protection: SIPC coverage in the U.S., additional insurance in some regions
  • Customer Support: 24/7 support via chat, phone, email; extensive educational resources

Security & Assurance

Both brokers employ rigorous security protocols, segregate client funds, and are subject to strict regulatory standards. IBKR’s long-standing reputation for transparency and security is well-established among professional traders.

Educational Resources & Research

AvaTrade

  • Offers comprehensive webinars, trading tutorials, eBooks, and economic calendars.
  • Specialized for beginners and intermediate traders.
  • Limited access to institutional research.

Interactive Brokers

  • Offers a vast array of webinars, in-depth research tools, and market analysis.
  • Advanced traders benefit from real-time data, analyst reports, and customizable research dashboards.
  • Strong emphasis on professional-grade research.

Account Types & Promotional Offers

AvaTrade

  • Accounts suitable for retail traders and institutional clients.
  • Demo accounts for practice.
  • Promotions are region-dependent and may include deposit bonuses.

Interactive Brokers

  • Offer a variety of account types: individual, joint, IRA, entity accounts.
  • Promotional offers are rare due to their low-fee structure.
  • Demo account available.

Which Broker Is Better for You?

This fundamental question hinges on your personal trading style, experience level, and your specific ambitions.

When AvaTrade Is a Better Fit:

  • Beginners and Casual Traders: Thanks to simplified interfaces and educational resources.
  • Forex & CFD Traders: Focused on forex, CFDs across multiple markets with a straightforward process.
  • Interest in Cryptocurrencies: Via CFDs with easy access.
  • Global Accessibility: Particularly in regions where AvaTrade has a strong regulatory presence.

When Interactive Brokers Is a Better Fit:

  • Active & Professional Traders: Low commissions, advanced trading tools.
  • Diverse Asset Portfolio: Access to stocks, options, futures, bonds, ETFs globally.
  • High-Volume Trading: Cost-efficient for large and frequent trades.
  • Institutional clients: Large accounts, sophisticated trading algorithms, professional research.

Customer Support & User Feedback

Customer support can make or break the trading experience, especially for new traders.

AvaTrade generally receives favorable reviews concerning customer service, especially in regions where they have established local support centers. Some users report delays or language barriers in certain support channels.

Interactive Brokers is renowned for quick, comprehensive support but may feel intimidating for less experienced traders due to its complex platform and procedures. However, they offer extensive educational resources to bridge this gap.

Final Verdict: Who Is the Better Broker?

Given the extensive comparison, the verdict largely depends on your individual trading needs and experience level.

  • Choose AvaTrade if:
    You are a beginner or casual trader primarily interested in forex, CFDs, and cryptocurrencies. You prefer a simple, user-friendly platform with solid educational tools.

  • Choose Interactive Brokers if:
    You are a professional or active trader seeking low costs, access to multiple markets, order execution speed, and advanced analytics and trading tools.

Both brokers are reputable, regulated, and offer excellent services, but their strengths cater to different segments of the trading community.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Which broker offers better educational resources?

AvaTrade provides more beginner-friendly educational content, including webinars, eBooks, and tutorials. Interactive Brokers offers extensive research and advanced market analysis, better suited for experienced traders.

2. Can I trade cryptocurrencies with both brokers?

Yes, both AvaTrade and Interactive Brokers offer cryptocurrency trading. AvaTrade provides CFDs on cryptos, while IBKR offers direct access to crypto via their platform.

3. Which broker has lower fees?

Generally, Interactive Brokers has lower commissions and spreads, making it more cost-effective, especially for high-volume traders.

4. Are both brokers regulated?

Yes, both are regulated by reputable agencies—AvaTrade across multiple jurisdictions, and Interactive Brokers primarily in the U.S. and Europe.

5. Which platform is easier to learn?

AvaTrade’s platforms are designed to be more intuitive for beginners, whereas Interactive Brokers’ TWS is more comprehensive but has a steeper learning curve.

6. Do both offer demo accounts?

Yes, both brokers provide demo accounts to practice trading without risking real money.

7. Is there a minimum deposit to open an account?

Minimum deposits vary but are generally low or zero for Interactive Brokers in the U.S. (IBKR Lite). AvaTrade’s minimum deposit depends on region but is typically accessible.

Conclusion

Deciding between AvaTrade and Interactive Brokers hinges upon what you prioritize most as a trader. If your goal is a user-friendly experience with a focus on forex and CFDs, AvaTrade provides a solid foundation. Conversely, if you’re a serious trader seeking broad asset access, thin spreads, and professional tools, Interactive Brokers is undoubtedly the superior choice.

In the end, both platforms have their unique advantages and limitations. It’s worthwhile to test both using demo accounts, assess the usability, fees, and available assets to see which aligns best with your trading ambitions. Remember, the right broker is the one that empowers you to trade confidently, securely, and effectively on your path to financial growth.

Leave a Comment